News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf] by z3t4 on Monday May 25, 2015 @10:41AM (#9600203)
One method that has proven to work good is to keep statistics and then nerf overused tactics and bump the ones that are rarely used. It will make some interesting game play!

Also try to have as much diversity as possible. This is one of my favorite quotes: "This game is so imbalanced so that it get balanced".

Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf] by fdej on Monday May 25, 2015 @11:27AM (#9600389)
Chess 1.1 changelog

  * nerfed movement for white pieces to balance out first-move advantage
  * added "undo" and "knight blast radius damage" DLC
Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf] by qznc on Monday May 25, 2015 @01:20PM (#9600858)
The author of the article actually has come up with "Chess 2". http://www.sirlingames.com/products/chess-2-print-and-play
Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf] by dkersten on Monday May 25, 2015 @12:46PM (#9600690)
Doesn't sound thaaat crazy. Go has the komi system, which gets updated occasionally - that is, white starts with points to compensate for blacks first-move advantage (currently 6.5 points in Japanese Go, but its been different over the years).
Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf] by detaro on Monday May 25, 2015 @12:07PM (#9600530)
Of course that means you need massive testing periods and/or have to patch things all the time (which takes effort, and can annoy players a lot), but for complex games that aren't extremely symmetrical it likely is the only way.

Are you thinking of any particular examples? First to my mind was Starcraft 2, which gets regular balance patches. And community bitching because the patches take to long/don't conform to everybody's pet theories/...

Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf] by z3t4 on Monday May 25, 2015 @01:53PM (#9600953)
Constant updates and patches are annoying, indeed! You have to be very delicate about what to change and what to add. If you manage to do it right though, it will make the game feel fresh and exciting for many years.

We all hate changes. Look for things that annoy ppl and try to fix those problems. Try to add new content, instead of changing old mechanics. This should be done slowly though, to give the mediate players a chance to get a hang of it. In a player vs player environment, it can take years for strategies to settle in, and for the majority of players to adapt.

Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf] by Vaskivo on Monday May 25, 2015 @12:52PM (#9600729)
> Also try to have as much diversity as possible. This is one of my favorite quotes: "This game is so imbalanced so that it get balanced".

That is embodied by the board game Cosmic Encounter.

It is a sci-fi negotiation game of space conquest. It has tons of special powers that effectivelly bend or break the rules. Some powers are so over-powered that the other players end up ganging up / never helping the OP player. (The game is best played with 5 players)

Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf] by DanTheManPR on Monday May 25, 2015 @02:42PM (#9601151)
Cosmic Encounter is the ur-example of a "balance through player interactions" type of game design (Diplomacy is another example). That is, there is just enough balance that one player cannot force a win by themselves, but there are otherwise gross imbalances in player power, and it is up to the players to maintain balance through temporary alliances and inevitable backstabbing. From my many plays of Cosmic Encounter, it does seem that the player with the strongest position does not win very much more often than others.

There are downsides to the design: one, it's hostile to new players who don't have enough knowledge of the game (this is true of any skill based multiplayer game, but in games like CE the effect of an unskilled player on the game can be profoundly wonky). The other issue I have is that players with a weak initial position have to win through negotiations, and so have fewer paths to victory than the players in powerful initial positions. I rarely ever see the "weak" player win in Cosmic Encounter (whereas the moderately-powerful and very-powerful players seem to have about equal chance at winning if they're playing competently).

Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf] by highCs on Monday May 25, 2015 @11:13AM (#9600343)
EDIT: I'm updating my profile with an email address, can you please send me an email?
Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf] by tomjen3 on Monday May 25, 2015 @12:19PM (#9600569)
Completely hijacking here, but if you haven't updated your profile to include an email do so now. I have gotten several interesting mails and no spam that I know of.
Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf] by DanBC on Monday May 25, 2015 @12:29PM (#9600615)
... And the email address needs to go in the "about" box, not just in the "email" field.