Re:Persistence of Long-Term Memory in Vitrified and Revived ...
by gwern on Saturday May 23, 2015 @10:07PM
(#9595080)
This is a good question. There's a lot of active research into chemical fixation and then doing brain scanning on thin slices to reconstruct the connectome and other features, with regular progress like "High-resolution whole-brain staining for electron microscopic circuit reconstruction", Mikula & Denk 2015 http://connectomes.org/pdf/mikula2015_.pdf . I have some more links in http://www.gwern.net/plastination
The upsides to chemical fixation or plastination is that you avoid issues with temporary interruptions in cooling (as far as we know, Alcor and CI have a nearly perfect record in maintaining LN2 coldness, but one could wonder how well that will work for the next century) since a fixated brain will be stable at room temperature, and you can have a much more quantifiable idea how much progress has been made in fixation and scanning through things like the BPF's prizes (http://www.brainpreservation.org/). So that makes this attractive.
The downside is that there is no infrastructure setup (there's no one you can go to and say "here's $10k, please wait by my bedside and as soon as I'm declared legally dead, dunk my head in osmium"), and the concerns about cryonics being too slow are magnified massively - people are worried about vitrification taking several hours and cryonics possibly being too late, but the current fixation solutions take more on the order of a month and don't necessarily fixate the entire brain volume. So you may get a great preservation which can be easily stored and imaged at high quality without any concerns about how to heat it back up... but what will you be imaging?
If I died tomorrow, I would go with regular cryonics hands-down no contest. But in 30 years? If Mikula, Hayworth, the BPF, Seung, etc keep on pushing forward this area, maybe then plastination will be equal or superior.
The upsides to chemical fixation or plastination is that you avoid issues with temporary interruptions in cooling (as far as we know, Alcor and CI have a nearly perfect record in maintaining LN2 coldness, but one could wonder how well that will work for the next century) since a fixated brain will be stable at room temperature, and you can have a much more quantifiable idea how much progress has been made in fixation and scanning through things like the BPF's prizes (http://www.brainpreservation.org/). So that makes this attractive.
The downside is that there is no infrastructure setup (there's no one you can go to and say "here's $10k, please wait by my bedside and as soon as I'm declared legally dead, dunk my head in osmium"), and the concerns about cryonics being too slow are magnified massively - people are worried about vitrification taking several hours and cryonics possibly being too late, but the current fixation solutions take more on the order of a month and don't necessarily fixate the entire brain volume. So you may get a great preservation which can be easily stored and imaged at high quality without any concerns about how to heat it back up... but what will you be imaging?
If I died tomorrow, I would go with regular cryonics hands-down no contest. But in 30 years? If Mikula, Hayworth, the BPF, Seung, etc keep on pushing forward this area, maybe then plastination will be equal or superior.