>We disagree with Reddit and other social democratic communities insofar that the view of a "safe platform" can be forced upon one another without resulting in a system that betrays the very meaning of the word "democratic". Rather, as illustrated by Frizbee, a successful establishment of a "safe platform" as we define it is a direct result of a culture built by the mutual trust users feel in their freedom.
I think I get it. The site redefines the phrase “safe platform” to mean what they want it to mean, instead of coining a new phrase, like “extreme freedom.”
> a culture built by the mutual trust users feel in their freedom.
If this catches on, I think what we will see is a rapid culling of anyone who does not feel “safe” in this Brave New Online World, leading to a situation where those who remain do in fact trust the system to keep them safe from moderation.
Re:
by jiayo on Saturday May 23, 2015 @02:48PM
(#9593886)
> "Hi. Welcome to Frizbee. We don't censor or track you."
If you're so concerned about tracking, then why is Ghostery blocking "Facebook Connect" and "Facebook Custom Audience"?
Frizbee's "privacy policy" is:
> "Frizbee never collects or shares personal data. Even your email isn't asked for, and the only token we store for identification are the first 6 digits of your IP address. Furthermore, we recommend those under the age of 13 not to visit this website."
This is in violation of Facebook's terms, e.g.:
> "Obtain adequate consent from people before using any Facebook technology that allows us to collect and process data about them, including for example, our SDKs and browser pixels. When you use such technology, disclose to people in your privacy policy that you are enabling us to collect and process data about them."
(edit: What if my IP address is 4.5.6.7?)
(edit 2: In the 3 minutes since I posted this, the Facebook tracker has been removed.)
(edit 3: Any site that claims "we put a big focus on privacy" should be HTTPS-only.)
I don't see why an IP needs to be stored anyway - Identity can be proved using other methods, like PGP signatures and "tripcodes" used by 4chan, 8chan etc.
1) I click on "write a post". Hmm.. no list that matches what i want to post.
2) So I click on "Full List". Nothing happens.
3) I want to go back with the back button. The back button does not work.
That is it.
Dudes.. I appreciate your fancy animations and that you do a decentralized whatever. But what I would like even more: if stuff works!
Exactly. If you want to be a privacy-focused competitor to reddit you can't count on users flocking to the service because of your ethics (unfortunately). Instead you have to focus on being the best experience for the user, and in addition be privacy-focused.
If it's harder to user your service or if it's a less satisfying experience, I'm not going to use your service.
Sorry there! I honestly didn't expect this post to get this much attention on Hacker News, and the product is still in development, but I'll get right to it!
Re:
by skymt on Saturday May 23, 2015 @02:55PM
(#9593926)
No censorship, you say. Suppose I were to write a script that text-encodes a file and splits it up among a bunch of posts, and another that reverses the process, like the Usenet binary tools. Now suppose someone uses this to leak a highly-anticipated new album. You receive a DMCA request quickly followed by a strongly-worded letter from a Hollywood lawyer instructing you to take down the offending posts or face legal action. What do you do?
("Contact us" is broken, otherwise I'd send this privately, but since the service is just in testing: you should probably use XSRF tokens for voting.)
Copyright you can get away with.. what about child pornography? That's something that'll not only get you in big trouble, but your site can be secretly filtered and disappear from the Internet in various countries (such as the United Kingdom).
4chan has survived because of censorship. You know the "mods are asleep, post <X>" meme? That came from people posting high-resolution images of things which had child pornography hidden in them steganographically.
Technically, they don't even qualify for safe harbor protection since there's no registered agent, and their policy seems to be "we won't or can't remove anything for any reason".
So they might get a DMCA takedown request, but even if they comply with it they would still have liability and could still be sued.
How can it be 'decentralized' if it runs on a specific domain?
That's just another slashdot, who for all intents and purposes also do not censor anything, and reddit, who censor very very rarely and try to avoid it at all costs.
> Our devotion to this goal is further accentuated by our Public Legal License, which stipulates that all the content on Frizbee is in the public domain, making us as a governing entity irresponsible for its propagation.
Well, whatever it is, I guess being "decentralized" exempts you from copyright law.
I don’t quite understand Frizbee’s promise of freedom, on the other hand. They say they’re a “social news site”; do they ban non-news content then? how they determine whether something is news or not?
Hub’s set of rules basically defines its audience. Having complete freedom—not having any rules—means not having any audience. The feed would simply be overwhelmed with spam, and if you ban spam—you got the rules.
This is my personal nightmare, and is why I am horrified to show HN my projects. So much detail has been missed in both technical terms and otherwise that I might have missed myself. Really, it seems like an otherwise okay idea implemented with all the expertise of a undergrad at a hackathon. HN has seen this immediately and responded by tearing it to shreds.
That being said, this needed the constructive criticism. I hope the author[s] figure out how to make this something really great, and I think they can.
When I see the combination of "reddit alternative" and "no censorship", I see yet another attempt at creating a free haven for any kind of racist, sexist and generally bigoted abuse.
Which will always fail because a) that free haven already exists and called "the internet" and b) the target audience only thrive in places like Reddit, where they can troll, provoke, hurt and yet portray themselves as the oppressed victims whenever someone tells them to fuck off.
It's also extremely vulnerable to a legal challenge. If you don't take down copyright violations, child pornography, dox, stolen information, hate speech, etc. then you're in for a fun ride with the courts.
I think it's because of the animated cars that are driving along the top. That seems to be the problem for me. Just replying in case the frizbee team sees this.
The cart animations zoom the page in and out on my iPad, really annoying. When zoomed out I can only see the first story, zoomed in its all just white below the animations.
Viewing landscape and nothing but letting the page load. Mobile safari.
I think I get it. The site redefines the phrase “safe platform” to mean what they want it to mean, instead of coining a new phrase, like “extreme freedom.”
> a culture built by the mutual trust users feel in their freedom.
If this catches on, I think what we will see is a rapid culling of anyone who does not feel “safe” in this Brave New Online World, leading to a situation where those who remain do in fact trust the system to keep them safe from moderation.
If you're so concerned about tracking, then why is Ghostery blocking "Facebook Connect" and "Facebook Custom Audience"?
Frizbee's "privacy policy" is:
> "Frizbee never collects or shares personal data. Even your email isn't asked for, and the only token we store for identification are the first 6 digits of your IP address. Furthermore, we recommend those under the age of 13 not to visit this website."
This is in violation of Facebook's terms, e.g.:
> "Obtain adequate consent from people before using any Facebook technology that allows us to collect and process data about them, including for example, our SDKs and browser pixels. When you use such technology, disclose to people in your privacy policy that you are enabling us to collect and process data about them."
(edit: What if my IP address is 4.5.6.7?)
(edit 2: In the 3 minutes since I posted this, the Facebook tracker has been removed.)
(edit 3: Any site that claims "we put a big focus on privacy" should be HTTPS-only.)
Dudes.. I appreciate your fancy animations and that you do a decentralized whatever. But what I would like even more: if stuff works!
If it's harder to user your service or if it's a less satisfying experience, I'm not going to use your service.
Test of Hacker News' functionality? Why submit something that's not really working at all?
I look forward to returning when it works.
("Contact us" is broken, otherwise I'd send this privately, but since the service is just in testing: you should probably use XSRF tokens for voting.)
4chan has survived because of censorship. You know the "mods are asleep, post <X>" meme? That came from people posting high-resolution images of things which had child pornography hidden in them steganographically.
(No anti-XSRF tokens? Click here to vote for my post, then! http://frizbee.co/vote.php?dothis=that&q=42091)
(Edit: OMG! You can upvote infinitely! Just keep requesting the same page!)
(Edit 2: You can DOWNVOTE infinitely!)
So they might get a DMCA takedown request, but even if they comply with it they would still have liability and could still be sued.
That's just another slashdot, who for all intents and purposes also do not censor anything, and reddit, who censor very very rarely and try to avoid it at all costs.
Well, whatever it is, I guess being "decentralized" exempts you from copyright law.
Hub’s set of rules basically defines its audience. Having complete freedom—not having any rules—means not having any audience. The feed would simply be overwhelmed with spam, and if you ban spam—you got the rules.
That being said, this needed the constructive criticism. I hope the author[s] figure out how to make this something really great, and I think they can.
Which will always fail because a) that free haven already exists and called "the internet" and b) the target audience only thrive in places like Reddit, where they can troll, provoke, hurt and yet portray themselves as the oppressed victims whenever someone tells them to fuck off.
https:
"This server could not prove that it is frizbee.co"
Lookin at you /r/coontown
You should consider tweaking the font weights and contrast ratio, I have pretty good eyesight, but the bold light greys were uncomfortable to read.
Viewing landscape and nothing but letting the page load. Mobile safari.
It is not.