Could your experience here be confirmation bias? You remember the cases where you felt you should run but didn't and it went wrong, and forget those where you felt you should run but didn't and everything was just fine?
The other side is that if you leave, it's very hard to say what would have happened otherwise. You may feel you've dodged a bullet when there was in reality no gun.
"Gut feeling" is often boils down to a "compressed" rapid response, based on all of our previous experience, without having to go through all the reasoning and debating that we usually do.
It makes sense that quick reactions can be good if they're responding to things we have done many, many times before. It also makes sense that quick reactions can be very poor if they're responding to things that we've not done much.
It's the reason why you might get the feeling someone is lying to you without being able to name every single piece of body language that told you why.
The truth is nothing is perfect, the reason these discussions don't go anywhere is because you're going to insist on finding the imperfections and then try to exploit that to win.
That is your right, but I explained both what it is, and why it's often correct.
I'm just too old to let myself get pulled into one of these discussions, sorry.
The ways in which we respond to things instinctively is a topic I find both fascinating and incredibly important. Personally I think there is enough evidence to suggest we should be highly wary of ways in which we think that we don't carefully analyse. If I'm wrong I could be ignoring a very powerful way of quickly responding to things. I think that people who rely on gut instinct are putting themselves at risk of making worse decisions on important issues, or trusting others that operate in the same way.
I'm not going to keep poking, because there's no joy in talking to someone that doesn't want to respond, and certainly no joy in talking to someone who thinks that a discussion or debate is either something to be won or something where neither person should expect to come out with a different opinion.
Having learnt that lesson the hard way, I whole-heartedly agree. Our "gut" is the equivalent of a supercomputer against the hand-held, battery-powered rational part of our minds. And it is there for a reason. If your "gut" screams at you to just run, you should at least seriously consider walking away. Every time I failed to do so, I came to regret it.