Re:Quasar and Akka – a Comparison
by circlespainter on Thursday May 21, 2015 @08:21PM
(#9586080)
> I've been using Akka in combination with Scala's Futures, with Java 8's CompletableFutures, with Rx Observables, with in-house asynchronous queues and I can't see how Akka doesn't play nice.
Quasar doesn't introduce an async programming framework to work around threads inefficiencies, it simply gives you more efficient threads.
> You can do that [write REST endpoint] with Akka as well, I've done that, I don't see the problem there.
Without Quasar, for your services you can either use normal JAX-RS, which is based on Java's heavyweight threads, or Play (or Spray) which is non-standard and async.
With Quasar instead you can use standard JAX-RS with regular blocking code, but running on lightweight threads.
> the bit about "synchronous" and "blocking" code being easier (while cheating by patching connections) is bullshit [...] People should write asynchronous code throughout the entire call-stack [...]
Probably I don't understand because I don't know much about Gevent and Eventlet but for info about Quasar I/O pls. refer to my other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9585737.
As for async being the way to go, I don't agree and the many discussions about async code problems tell me I'm not alone in that.
Quasar doesn't introduce an async programming framework to work around threads inefficiencies, it simply gives you more efficient threads.
> You can do that [write REST endpoint] with Akka as well, I've done that, I don't see the problem there.
Without Quasar, for your services you can either use normal JAX-RS, which is based on Java's heavyweight threads, or Play (or Spray) which is non-standard and async. With Quasar instead you can use standard JAX-RS with regular blocking code, but running on lightweight threads.
> the bit about "synchronous" and "blocking" code being easier (while cheating by patching connections) is bullshit [...] People should write asynchronous code throughout the entire call-stack [...]
Probably I don't understand because I don't know much about Gevent and Eventlet but for info about Quasar I/O pls. refer to my other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9585737. As for async being the way to go, I don't agree and the many discussions about async code problems tell me I'm not alone in that.