News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by ChuckMcM on Thursday May 21, 2015 @07:44PM (#9585985)
As with most things it is somewhat more nuanced. Securities need people to buy them, otherwise they are illiquid and you can't do anything but stare at them :-). So having them go 'up' on their opening day creates a two point trend line that is up and to the right.

Of course anyone who has been around for a while has seen that IPOs always come down 6 - 12 months after they go out. Generally that is because regular employees will have a lock out period (so as not to flood the market) and that lockout is between 180 and 360 days. The interesting metric is that depending on when the employee was hired, their option price might be much much lower than what the current selling price is, and they will often make trades "at the market" which is code for put them on the sell side, I really don't care how much they go for. And the market maker will fill that order from the buy side with the sales price going down each time they fill up one tranche on the buy side and move to the next lower one. That pushes the price down, and depending on how many people are selling, potentially way down. So you will see a lot of option activity for "puts" at sales at those points as traders try to capitalize on the 'employee lockout dump'.

Of course what the bankers taking the company public do not want to have happen for any reason, is to not sell all of the shares that are in the offering. Often times the bankers will be obligated to buy any unsold shares at the offering price, and if the stock is going down that means the bankers are being forced to buy shares from the client company because nobody else wants to pay that price for them. Generally if that looks likely to happen they pull the IPO like Box did rather than lose money on the transaction.

Its these other factors which favors an IPO with a 20 - 50% up tick in price. It means all of the shares will issue without any overhang for the banker, it also makes sure that people are left with a perception of "value" on the stock (just as private financing round that leaves your shares more valuable than before is more positively perceived than a 'down' round where stock price is lower)

Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by manyhats on Thursday May 21, 2015 @09:27PM (#9586241)
Adding a little more detail on the mechanics of a typical capital markets raise to your answer, there's an overallotment on the "target" raise, which the bookrunner (lead underwriter) will use to stabilize the price.

For example, ABC Inc. wants to raise $100 in an IPO, and intends to sell 100 shares at $1. The underwriters will sell 115 shares at $1 (the extra 15 shares are the overallotment) and the company sells the bank 100 shares and grants the bank the option (but not the obligation) to purchase another 15 shares from the company for $1.

One bank from the underwriting syndicate will take responsibility to stabilize the price when the issue starts trading, which means that the initial sellers might be selling to "true" buyers, or if there aren't any above the IPO price, the bank.

If the price is above the IPO price once the stabilization period is over (30 days), and the bank hasn't bought back those "extra" 15 shares (in whole or part) during the period, the bank will call the extra shares from the company for $1 to close out their initial 15 share short position from the initial IPO overallocation, and instead of raising $100, the company will have raised $100+overallotment.

If the IPO priced too high, the bank will quickly run through its 15 share overallotment trying the stem the stock price fall and you'll see the price break through the IPO price. In this case, the bank naturally will have closed out the 15 share short position, and ABC Inc. will have raised the initial $100.

Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by nemo44x on Friday May 22, 2015 @09:34AM (#9588132)
This is known as a "Greenshoe Option". It got the name from a company called "Green Shoe Manufacturing" which was the first company to allow this practice.
Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by trhway on Thursday May 21, 2015 @09:36PM (#9586268)
i suppose there are reasons for those complexities, yet i can't not to wonder why a company just wouldn't put into the system on the opening day one huge limit (at "IPO" price) sale order and let the party begin.
Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by stygiansonic on Friday May 22, 2015 @01:22PM (#9589727)
Consider the effect of this - effectively this is saying the company should put in a huge limit SELL limit order at the IPO price ("Limit SELL 100,000,000, @ $10.00") and leave it open all day. This would almost certainly bias the price movement on the stock downward because:

1) In order for the price to rise above $10.00, there would have to be enough buyers out there to fill the entire limit order. There's no guarantee of that.

2) Consequently, if the first few buyers start to trade their stock and the price falls below $10.00, the initial "IPO Limit Order" could never get filled. Essentially, the company does not know how much capital they would raise.

The standard underwriting/IPO process aims to remove this risk. It's not really removed, however, and really just transferred to the underwriters. However, the underwriters have better ability to deal with/mitigate the risk because of their abilities in this area. (Gauging investor sentiment through roadshows, use of greenshoe/reverse greenshoe options, etc.)

The idea is that the IPO price is set conservatively to ensure the underwriters don't take a loss. This "spread" between the IPO price and the "true" price is part of the fee they take. (I'm not arguing whether it's a lot of money, just providing the details) The key part of this is that it's hard to know what the "true" price will be on IPO day, and hence, what your IPO price should be. It's the underwriters' job to help determine this.

Note that in your example, you could just set the IPO/Limit price so low that you know the entire sell order will get filled. But this naturally leads to the question: What should I set the IPO price to, to ensure the most amount of capital ("don't leave any money on the table") while still ensuring the order is filled? Again, this is a service that the underwriters would provide and is something that most companies probably don't know how to do.

(Note that the situation in (1) and (2) is also why you would never want to put in a huge standing limit order; it will push the price away from you and effectively acts as an option for other traders to "lean on")

Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by ChuckMcM on Friday May 22, 2015 @02:50PM (#9590222)
Something to consider is that these complexities are emergent, they are not architected. Years and years of experience with different banks trying to get the best return for the company going public (in order to be the bank most likely to take a company public) is a fitness function. And over the years various strategies evolve based on what has come before them. That is why when folks like Google decide to do things really really differently it causes everyone to both flee in terror and watch intently :-).