News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by tedsanders on Thursday May 21, 2015 @04:51PM (#9585305)
So true. It's bizarre how journalists report on IPOs. I imagine it comes from the search for an easy narrative (e.g., "Investors raced to shop for SHOP"), but these narratives always miss the point that a pop indicates underestimated demand, not high demand.

Suppose I took Facebook public and sold the company for $10 to my friends, who turned around and sold it for $10 billion. The stock would have experienced a billion-fold IPO, but Facebook would not be happy that they only got $10. The bigger the IPO pop, the more money your company left on the table.

Here's an article I wrote a year ago discussing this very issue: "IPOs: The one topic journalists always get wrong" http://www.tedsanders.com/ipos/

Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by bickfordb on Thursday May 21, 2015 @05:17PM (#9585439)
It seems like this is a good argument for not going public. You have to pay a 5% tax to bankers and sell shares to institutional investors at what often appears to be a 50% discount
Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by Scoundreller on Thursday May 21, 2015 @05:47PM (#9585570)
But liquidity is valuable, and may be worth all the costs. The average P/E ratio for the stock market is ~15, while a small private business will only have a ratio of 3 or 4.
Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by cma on Thursday May 21, 2015 @11:32PM (#9586475)
You can't compare the average nonpublic company with the average public company to come to the conclusion that companies should go public. You are including small plumbing businesses, etc. That realistically will never have a chance to go public, with large businesses that were successful enough to go public.
Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by tim333 on Friday May 22, 2015 @05:39AM (#9587314)
Or you can follow the Google model and do a Dutch auction.
Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by nemo44x on Friday May 22, 2015 @09:39AM (#9588158)
Good luck finding an underwriter willing to do that if you're not a company like Google.
Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by JonFish85 on Thursday May 21, 2015 @07:03PM (#9585880)
"Facebook would not be happy that they only got $10."

The question I would ask is: "who is it that isn't happy"? Employees? Their stock options are worth the same regardless of what the IPO price is. Investors? Same thing. New investors? They're getting an immediate return. I mean sure, the company doesn't get as much to put in the bank, but ultimately who is upset about that?

Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by dsg42 on Thursday May 21, 2015 @07:18PM (#9585926)
The company itself, which essentially just lost the difference in cost between the IPO shares and their actual value in cash.

Okay, if you want to be really nitpicky, they didn't lose quite that amount. But they did lose a substantial amount of cash.

Also, employees are likely hurt indirectly, as they can't sell their stock for 90 days. Underpriced IPOs flood the market with stock, potentially causing the price to collapse (as in the case of LendingClub) before they get to cash out.

Re:Shopify IPO shares soar in trading debut by joshu on Thursday May 21, 2015 @07:17PM (#9585920)
Really? Can you think a bit more about this one?