Re:The Definition of Evil: Microsoft's Search Wars Hurt Us All
by dagw on Monday November 23, 2009 @05:51PM
(#958313)
The Paramount case was more about vertical integration than exclusive deals. Since Microsoft and News Corp are two completely separate companies I don't really see how that case applies.
Had Microsoft been making msnbc content exclusively available through bing then there might have been a case, but making a deal with News Corp shouldn't step on any of the ground covered by the Paramount case.
Furthermore, I would make the argument that this is much different from signing a contract with a publisher. On the contrary, I would say this is akin to a movie theater paying a movie studio to keep a movie out of its competitor's theaters. This exact scenario was ruled to be a violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act: (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pict...)
This sounds to me as though it's the exact type of anticompetitive action things like the Sherman Antitrust Act were meant to prevent.
*Edit, added link to Paramount case