The reason that we have persist identifiers with mobile phones historically is all about billing and call completion. If we did the billing and call completion at other layers that weren't tied to a mobile subscriber's identity, we could ditch the persistent identifiers and use much more temporary ones (much like you could still get on a wifi network with DHCP even if you changed your MAC address every 5 minutes, and you could also netcat anonymous voucher tokens to a network provider's server to prove your entitlement to receive connectivity).
(I think the Guardian Project has tried making actual VoIP calls over TCP over Tor, and I don't know how well it worked out for them. So I'm assuming you won't be able to route the media streams anonymously, maybe just the control channel.)
True, but cellphones are constantly checking in to the network, even if they aren't transmitting any actual data. In theory, a cellphone could remain passive, waiting for a pager-like signal indicating there's an inbound connection waiting, and then iff the user wants to accept it, indicate its current position to the network.
I suppose a poor-man’s version could be achieved by carrying both a pager and a cellphone (turned off or in airplane mode), and having a gateway that would retransmit your SMSs and missed call notifications to the pager.
So you page the entire network globally to find the device?
Or locally, and have the device check in when it enters a new geographic area instead of all the time. The accuracy of passive tracking could be decreased considerably if the protocols were designed with that goal in mind.
This is one of those cases where perfect is the enemy of good. Just because there will always be the possibility of tracking in wireless networks, does not mean that that we can not work on minimising that leak.
How do you imagine participating in a network such that it isn't tracking you?
- Identifying which port/antenna it's receiving you on (i.e. switching tables, tower pings) is tracking.
- Tagging your traffic with your unique identifier (i.e. MAC and IP addresses) is tracking.
- Figuring out where to send replies to your requests is impossible without extensive, persistent tracking.
How do you have network without these things?
It's true that carrying a smartphone entails being tracked more than not carrying electronics, but it's unclear how you could have a phone that doesn't track you while still functioning as a phone.
Perhaps a pager? They passively receive encrypted satellite broadcasts. But then, they are receive-only devices. You can't transmit things without facilitating the tracking of where you are transmitting from.