Re:The Definition of Evil: Microsoft's Search Wars Hurt Us All
by gojomo on Monday November 23, 2009 @03:18PM
(#958053)
The idea you could index a site against its wishes remains to be tested; the custom so far has been not to do so. Google tried indexing books without rightsholder permission, then backed down.
If NewsCorp, NYTimesCo, WashingtonPost, ComcastNBC, etc. are unified against the idea of indexing-as-fair-use, and if (for business strategic reasons), the deep-pocketed MSFT and Google decide they can live with paying-for-permission (as a useful barrier to upstarts), who will prove the case in the courts or legislature?
If NewsCorp, NYTimesCo, WashingtonPost, ComcastNBC, etc. are unified against the idea of indexing-as-fair-use, and if (for business strategic reasons), the deep-pocketed MSFT and Google decide they can live with paying-for-permission (as a useful barrier to upstarts), who will prove the case in the courts or legislature?