Re:NYSE launches a Bitcoin index
by tlrobinson on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @11:02AM
(#9576774)
Interesting. It seems like a classic "tragedy of the commons" situation. Even if miners want to see Bitcoin succeed (in order to get a return on their mining hardware investment), at some point they have to join the alternating adjustment period schedule to remain profitable, making the problem worse, and riding the sinking ship down...
The question is what is the "activation energy" required to initiate the oscillations. Is a large miner (how large?) likely to attempt this knowing the ultimate outcome?
And more importantly, can it be fixed? The protocol isn't set in stone.
You are wrong as characterising this as negative-feedback, this is positive feedback because if you are presented with a situation where in even "weeks" (which now last 6 days) the difficulty is 10% less than odd weeks (which now last 8 days), then you will join mining only the easy weeks which further feedsback to more distortion.
edit to add: I realise the adjustment period is not aimed to be 7 days, this is for easier illustration.