News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NYSE launches a Bitcoin index by nostrademons on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @06:08AM (#9575360)
So are all assets. It's one of the quirks of capitalism that markets remain efficient only to the extent that people believe that they're inefficient, and liquid only to the extent that people are misinformed about an asset's value. To see why, imagine a perfectly efficient asset market with perfect information, where the goal of every participant is to maximize their financial returns. In such a market, all participants know everything that all other participants do, they know that all other participants know everything they do, and they can transact instantaneously without cost. Prices in this market converge instantly upon the "true" value, which can be agreed upon by all market partipants because of their omniscience. Such a market has zero liquidity. Why would anyone transact if they know that a security already has the correct value? For there to be profit potential, the person who sells to you must be misinformed about the security's true value, which contradicts the assumption of omniscience. The interesting thing is that the more market participants believe in the market's efficiency, the more inefficient it becomes. With little incentive to do their own research (why bother, when the current price reflects more information than they could possibly amass?), the underlying fundamental value of the asset can drift further from the consensus price without anyone noticing. This increases the profit potential for people who assume that they know better than everyone else. Eventually, a few of them get rich, the consensus breaks down, lots of people lose their shirts, and the market becomes efficient again. The result is the business cycle. Periods where people believe in the market's efficiency are bubbles (when the consensus price is above the true value) and panics (when the consensus price is below the true value). Periods when they don't are crises, where the prevailing momentum swings but this change in opinion is unevenly distributed. Lots of things fundamental to the modern world are unstable. The whole concept of a financial asset is one of them. I can think of a number of individual industries that have an unstable dynamic, but I'm not going to name them because I believe there's profit potential in them. Public opinion is yet another one.
Re:NYSE launches a Bitcoin index by nevi-me on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @07:13AM (#9575561)
Even if participants all have perfect information, I feel like you're forgetting something fundamental to instruments, at least primary instruments. If I buy an instrument, I'm expecting returns, I don't buy primarily to speculate, but to gain returns, which can be fixed or variable. So for say a sovereign state with little credit risk, why do funds but the state's government bonds? Because there is contractual income to gain. There will always be someone wanting to sell and let go off that income, because for most people money is an utility that is accumulated to be used. On the other side, even in a perfect market, there will always be someone who has received the money from the spender, and wants to get income from that instrument.

Or is there something I'm missing?

Re:NYSE launches a Bitcoin index by yincrash on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @10:47AM (#9576663)
People trade in ForEx (possibly more than any other market?). Holding currency doesn't have a contractual return.
Re:NYSE launches a Bitcoin index by danbruc on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @06:42AM (#9575452)
I think your conclusion of zero liquidity is wrong because there will still be people entering and exiting the market.
Re:NYSE launches a Bitcoin index by kristopolous on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @06:38AM (#9575436)
Would you mind breaking that up into paragraphs... It's easier to read that way
Re:NYSE launches a Bitcoin index by ximeng on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @09:47AM (#9576246)
So are all assets.

It's one of the quirks of capitalism that markets remain efficient only to the extent that people believe that they're inefficient, and liquid only to the extent that people are misinformed about an asset's value. To see why, imagine a perfectly efficient asset market with perfect information, where the goal of every participant is to maximize their financial returns.

In such a market, all participants know everything that all other participants do, they know that all other participants know everything they do, and they can transact instantaneously without cost. Prices in this market converge instantly upon the "true" value, which can be agreed upon by all market partipants because of their omniscience.

Such a market has zero liquidity. Why would anyone transact if they know that a security already has the correct value? For there to be profit potential, the person who sells to you must be misinformed about the security's true value, which contradicts the assumption of omniscience.

The interesting thing is that the more market participants believe in the market's efficiency, the more inefficient it becomes. With little incentive to do their own research (why bother, when the current price reflects more information than they could possibly amass?), the underlying fundamental value of the asset can drift further from the consensus price without anyone noticing. This increases the profit potential for people who assume that they know better than everyone else. Eventually, a few of them get rich, the consensus breaks down, lots of people lose their shirts, and the market becomes efficient again.

The result is the business cycle. Periods where people believe in the market's efficiency are bubbles (when the consensus price is above the true value) and panics (when the consensus price is below the true value). Periods when they don't are crises, where the prevailing momentum swings but this change in opinion is unevenly distributed.

Lots of things fundamental to the modern world are unstable. The whole concept of a financial asset is one of them. I can think of a number of individual industries that have an unstable dynamic, but I'm not going to name them because I believe there's profit potential in them. Public opinion is yet another one.

Re:NYSE launches a Bitcoin index by nostrademons on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @04:03PM (#9578900)
Thanks. I had it in paragraphs originally, but copied & pasted it back in from the back button after accidentally deleting it and the formatting didn't copy over.