News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will Computers Redefine the Roots of Math? by brudgers on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @07:57PM (#9573898)
I think so, because just the fact that mathematicians are using Coq and other tools means that it has already begun. But the big important changes aren't what happens at the Phd level. It's what happens down at the ordinary level of arithmetic and the sorts of notation that are useful for doing ordinary computations. Public schools need to be using J [1] as a way of both expanding notation and a practical way of leveraging the computer as a mathematical instrument.

Infix operation and order of precedence make sense when we're working with pencils...well ok order of precedence beyond nesting with parenthesis doesn't make sense then either...but why make a computer notation constrained by rules that happen to have grown up around manual process?

[1] http://jsoftware.com

Re:Will Computers Redefine the Roots of Math? by tempodox on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @04:14AM (#9575053)
I took a quick look at J and find it rather obscure. Can only guess that the computation model is something procedural. A language so far off the beaten path should have better introductory documentation. Can it to more than shuffle character arrays?
Re:Will Computers Redefine the Roots of Math? by brudgers on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @08:57AM (#9575969)
This is a good resource for onboarding with J:

http://www.jsoftware.com/jwiki/Books#Math_for_the_Layman

J is as easy to pick up as using an ordinary calculator. Reading J can be as hard as reading mathematical notation. It is obscure in the same way as any other mathematical notation. What does:

   x
signify in a third grade classroom? J is off the beaten path of programming languages because it is designed to be immediately useful for mathematics, and not just the higher level Phd stuff, but ordinary tasks that 3rd graders perform.

It looks unusual because it starts from the point of view of notation and is compact in exactly the same way that

  *
is compact in C, Python, VBA etc. It is directly applicable in a third grade classroom because:

   3 * 4
   3 x 4
   3 times 4
are isomorphic notations. What J does is extend the number of notations that are accessible from the Latin character set encoding to include compact notations for counting and summing and all sorts of other things. But it still provides the sort of operations that are useful to young students and which they commonly perform on a calculator.
Re:Will Computers Redefine the Roots of Math? by tempodox on Thursday May 21, 2015 @08:27AM (#9582203)
Your answer told me more about J than the web pages I'v seen. If you put it that way, J might even whet my curiosity.
Re:Will Computers Redefine the Roots of Math? by brudgers on Thursday May 21, 2015 @08:59AM (#9582367)
Ken Iverson won a Turing Award largely on the back of APL. After 30 years of field use, he developed J in the late 1980's to in part address its shortcomings. Then for two decades he sold J as a commercial product. More recently it was GPL'd.

Math for the Layman is only the tip of the iceberg fro what lives on jsoftware.com. And it all tends to be about that level of quality.