Re:Instead of elections, let's use lotteries
by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @07:16PM
(#9573753)
> Elections are flawed and can’t be redeemed
Elections in the US may be flawed, but there is quite a bit of evidence that other electoral systems -- particularly, ones where the main legislative body isn't elected by FPTP in single-member districts -- work much better at providing meaningful democratic accountability, which is where the article sees the failure of elections.
So, while I accept the conclusions that US elections are flawed, I don't accept the more general claim, or the claim that even US elections can't be redeemed.
Sortition is interesting, and may be useful, and is certainly something that it makes sense to try on a smaller scale. But better election systems are both a less radical change and one more supported as effective in the modern world and conditions by evidence which provides a clear idea of how to structure them.
Elections in the US may be flawed, but there is quite a bit of evidence that other electoral systems -- particularly, ones where the main legislative body isn't elected by FPTP in single-member districts -- work much better at providing meaningful democratic accountability, which is where the article sees the failure of elections.
So, while I accept the conclusions that US elections are flawed, I don't accept the more general claim, or the claim that even US elections can't be redeemed.
Sortition is interesting, and may be useful, and is certainly something that it makes sense to try on a smaller scale. But better election systems are both a less radical change and one more supported as effective in the modern world and conditions by evidence which provides a clear idea of how to structure them.