News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by gtirloni on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @12:41PM (#9571373)
It gives you the bare minimum you need to schedule and start containerized workloads and leaves the rest to however you want to build and deploy your software

Isn't this a bit of pushing the problem somewhere else? It seems that complexity will be "load balanced" to all the containers owners, which is great for infrastructure owners but does it "solve" the underlying problem (as it's stated in the article)?

Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by abhay_agarwal on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @01:26PM (#9571677)
Container-friendly OSes are definitely the future. While CoreOS isn't the only one (Atomic, Photon, Snappy), there's very little need for most OS features that we traditionally expect in servers when lightweight containers wrap all our applications, and cluster schedulers manage failover.

As for load-balancing the problem, there actually is added complexity in new architectures because we add a layer of orchestration on top. However, that layer on top is becoming more and more necessary, so it makes sense to move a lot of functionality out of the OS layer.

If you want an example, think about how modern disk systems expect JBOD instead of RAID. When there is innovation on top, the underlying system can become simpler.

Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by stresler on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @12:49PM (#9571438)
Yes, exactly. That is what the final sentence was meant to indicate,

"We’re moving past the days where we take an operating system off the shelf and plug things into it until it can serve our application and into the days of purpose built OSes that push software complexity into the realm of software engineer."

I wasn't trying to indicate that we 'solved' this, but rather that the approach of managing software in the OS layer was putting it in the wrong place.

Configuration management is definitely still a problem. But I think handling it in a compartmentalized area separate from the base OS makes sense.

Thanks for the feedback.

Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by digi_owl on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @06:13AM (#9575369)
Seems like a trend these days. Tired of dealing with a hairball of code? Put it up a layer and let them handle it instead...

I'm seeing it with TTYs, i'm seeing it with mice, it seems to be going on all over the place...