News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Life Is “Triggering.” the Best Literature Should Be, Too by pavlov on Monday May 18, 2015 @01:42PM (#9565782)
It's basically young rape victims asking to be warned when a lecture/reading is going to contain descriptions of rape.

Is that really a reasonable request in a literature class? Does the same apply to any traumatic event and any field of study -- for example, if a medical student was robbed at knifepoint, should he be given advance warning about seeing blood or cut skin...?

The quoted passage specifically mentions "people of color or students from a low-income background" in addition to survivors. How is that meant to be interpreted? What kind of writing do poor students need to be protected against?

Re:Life Is “Triggering.” the Best Literature Should Be, Too by nmrm2 on Monday May 18, 2015 @02:18PM (#9566012)
My point was that comparing warnings with Orwellian censorship is hyperbolic.

The first question you ask is already covered well in other discussion threads.

The second question I don't have an answer to. But that's the problem with trying to have productive conversations about a broad statement from a student group instead of discussing current and proposed concrete policies/policy proposals. In general, unless there's a concrete policy proposal on the table, we should tend to assume the best of people and avoid conjuring up Orwellian nightmares out of vague statements.

Re:Life Is “Triggering.” the Best Literature Should Be, Too by jtbigwoo on Monday May 18, 2015 @02:15PM (#9565994)
I'm getting off the topic, but my friends that referee high-level children's sports were talking about how taunting rules and trash talk have changed over the years. In the past decade or two, they're really tried to stamp out racial and sexual trash talk. Now they're encouraged to watch out for trash talk regarding economic class. The reasoning is two-fold. First, kids are getting smarter. If you call someone a racial slur you get kicked out of the league, but maybe you can tell them their mother's on welfare or their dad is an illegal immigrant. Second, children's sports are so much about money. High-level children's sports are pay-to-play. Top-tier club teams in many sports can cost $10k/year or more. The fact that there are any lower-income kids in the leagues at all is kind of surprising. Usually the less talented, richer kids are subsidizing a handful of more talented poorer kids. Some kids will do whatever it takes to get an edge or maybe even get the other teams best player to throw a punch and get kicked out.
Re:Life Is “Triggering.” the Best Literature Should Be, Too by DanBC on Monday May 18, 2015 @05:42PM (#9567026)
(I just accidentally downvoted you. Sorry.)

The article mangles two concepts:

1) Trigger Warnings

2) Safe Spaces

Both of these are being misused in some universities. Providing a warning to vulnerable people so that they can keep themself safe is fair enough. But some people point to the safe space policy and suggest that the trigger warning is not sufficient and that the material should not be taught.