Re:Rare book experts join forces to stop tome raiders
by userbinator on Sunday May 17, 2015 @09:21PM
(#9562468)
The "freedom" they refer to there is probably "free as in libre", not "free as in gratis" - they are allowed to provide you with that information, and if it's public-domain you can do whatever you want with it afterwards, but they are allowed to charge you for the labour of doing it.
Re:Rare book experts join forces to stop tome raiders
by pbhjpbhj on Monday May 18, 2015 @09:43AM
(#9564344)
AIUI under FoI they can charge an admin fee, IIRC that's of the order of £10. That would be considerably cheaper than £400 mentioned.
<a few seconds of research ensues ...>
https://www.justice.gov.uk/information-access-rights/foi-gui... mentions £25 per hour. Assuming that the images are already on BL computers somewhere then them providing a link or sending them by email would likely be a couple of minutes; with admin certainly within the hour.
FoI is about free-libre but they can't put financial blocks in the way as that's undemocratic, it would make the FoI only accessible to the rich.
Re:Rare book experts join forces to stop tome raiders
by userbinator on Monday May 18, 2015 @10:09AM
(#9564480)
Assuming that the images are already on BL computers somewhere then them providing a link or sending them by email would likely be a couple of minutes; with admin certainly within the hour.
I read his comment as meaning they haven't digitised them (yet), and BL wants £400 to do it. Not that I agree with charging that much as I think they should've done that already, but if he's asking for a bunch of large, old, and fragile images, it could be delicate and time-consuming work.
http://www.bl.uk/aboutus/foi/overview/
However, I'm sure the BL have lawyers standing by ready to stop you under one of the mentioned - but not disclosed - "exemptions" in the above link.