News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Plot Against Trains by dragonwriter on Friday May 15, 2015 @04:19PM (#9553399)
> I think that valid government only exists as the collective extension of our innate right to self-defense, and do no support government involvement in anything else.

I would note that this is expressly at odds with the model of government enshrined in the Constitution (and I mean, even the original text + bill of rights, not later amendments), which clearly envisions even the federal government as having a much larger role than as "the collective extension of our innate right to self-defense", at least as one would normally conceive that phrase.

And, I'd further note, that I can't see any government not empowered to take action to internalize external costs and benefits of economic transactions as being worthwhile, or in fact of such a minimal government as being anything but oppressive-in-effect. Of course, on the externalized cost side, one could view such costs as a form of violence (unconsented harm inflicted by others), and defending against them as part of the innate right of self-defense, and then the limitation on government you propose would still admit a government empowered to address economic externalities. At which point, defending government involvement in transit becomes a lot easier, even within the framework you set out.

Re:The Plot Against Trains by mindcrime on Friday May 15, 2015 @04:25PM (#9553442)
I would note that this is expressly at odds with the model of government enshrined in the Constitution (and I mean, even the original text + bill of rights, not later amendments), which clearly envisions even the federal government as having a much larger role than as "the collective extension of our innate right to self-defense", at least as one would normally conceive that phrase.

Agreed. But I never said I thought the Constitution was a big deal, or the model for perfect government. As it happens, I have a LOT of issues with pretty much all aspects of our government as it exists today.

That said, I do wish they'd at least play by their own rules, as a federal government strictly bound by the Constitution would almost certainly be smaller and less corrupt than what we have now. But nobody really seems to give a shit about the Constitution these days.