"Amtrak Northeast makes money, quite a lot in fact, but it is used to subsidize other regions that lose buckets of money."
Can you site your source for that including continuing capital spending?
So, asking someone to cite a source on HN is now worthy of down votes?
Do you also oppose highways? They are an (almost) entirely public endeavour, they aren't even funded solely by usage fees in the form of gas tax. In fact 42% of highway funding comes from general funds(like income tax). And, most of them are giant money pits.