News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Witness Accounts Show the Power of False Memory by tptacek on Friday May 15, 2015 @11:26AM (#9551208)
This is spelled out in the General Order documents of every US police department.

Virtually all police are authorized --- in fact, trained & required --- to use deadly force to "protect themselves or another person from imminent death or serious bodily injury". A credible hammer swing to their partner's head obviously qualifies.

Unlike in other situations, they aren't supposed to carefully judge the minimum possible level of force. If "imminent death or serious bodily injury" is at stake, they are trained to use firearms.

No cop in that situation wants to try to grapple with the attacker --- he's about 8-10 feet away from the officer when he brandishes his weapon --- only to fail to prevent the hammer strike that paralyzes his partner.

There's a legit public policy debate to be had about whether US foot police should be outfitted and trained more like UK police, so that most of them don't have firearms at all. But it's not fair to single these officers out. If we're going to evaluate this incident under the rubric of "a good shooting", as you did, it's hard to see how this doesn't qualify.

Re:Witness Accounts Show the Power of False Memory by chernevik on Friday May 15, 2015 @12:35PM (#9551735)
Yes, it's unfair to single out these cops. But the standard they've met here, and the training and capabilities behind that standard, are a problem.

Once the attacker misses on his first swing, I doubt the officer attacked is in grave danger. I think it is reasonable to expect a police officer to fend off a guy with a hammer, certainly long enough for her partner to get behind the guy and grab him. Someone who can't do that isn't qualified for the job.

And isn't clear to me that either of these officers made the right tactical choices in the first place. The shooter was very lucky that the attacker ended up in a position where he could take a clean shot.

Re:Witness Accounts Show the Power of False Memory by jobu on Friday May 15, 2015 @11:45AM (#9551334)
I think the point chernevik was trying to make is that the officer appears to be shooting the attacker when the attacker is between the officers. Unless that bullet hits a bone it's going to pass through the guy and hit the other officer or possibly an innocent bystander. Even if it does hit a bone it could pass through the guy expanded or fragmented and still cause significant damage. (Unless they're using frangible bullets, but I haven't heard of that outside air marshals.)
Re:Witness Accounts Show the Power of False Memory by tptacek on Friday May 15, 2015 @11:48AM (#9551357)
That is a general problem with having armed police in heavily populated areas, and one I recognize and agree with (I don't like guns).

That said: the NYPD General Order doesn't exempt police in NYC from using firearms to prevent imminent death or bodily harm.

I've known police from other states who visited my family in Chicago and carried their firearms with them. (Again: I don't like guns). When I asked why they had them, I got a speech about how they were required to carry them.

Re:Witness Accounts Show the Power of False Memory by XJOKOLAT on Friday May 15, 2015 @11:56AM (#9551413)
In many cases, I've always wondered this:

Why not just shoot the legs? Why does it have to be "deadly force"?

Just asking. My knowledge of this subject ends at watching Schwarzenegger target legs in T2.

Re:Witness Accounts Show the Power of False Memory by dionidium on Friday May 15, 2015 @12:22PM (#9551620)
It's funny that you reference T2, because the usual snarky reply to your question is that that only works in the movies.

The whole point is that you're trying to neutralize a deadly threat. It's no time for target practice or carnival games. Someone is attacking you with a deadly weapon. It is time to neutralize that threat at all costs.

I appreciate the instinct to preserve life. That shows a level of empathy that I respect a great deal. But I think it's an eccentric position. Most people are of the opinion that you lose the right to your own safety when you make a threat on another person's life.

Re:Witness Accounts Show the Power of False Memory by tptacek on Friday May 15, 2015 @12:02PM (#9551461)
Because (a) the legs are much harder to hit and (b) a hit to the legs is much less likely to incapacitate an attacker.

The whole premise of them shooting is that there's an imminent threat. If they're shooting, it's supposed to be because they MUST incapacitate the attacker.

From what I've read, not only are they supposed to aim at the center of the target, but they're also not supposed to shoot just once. A single gunshot will kill someone, but not instantly, and in the time it takes for that wound to incapacitate them, they might go on to kill someone else.

Which when you think about it is the worst of both worlds: the police kill someone, and that person still manages to kill someone else.

A little later.

I was curious enough about this to make sure I wasn't just making this up (power of false memories and all that). Some arguments against "shooting to wound":

* It supposedly takes ~250ms to fire a round under optimal conditions, and just ~150ms to rotate/translate a limb from one side of the body to another; the target moves faster than the officer can shoot.

* Increased likelihood of missing the target also implies an increased likelihood of hitting something that isn't a target (again: something I would agree militates for officers not shooting at all, but still).

* The places on limbs where you're most likely to hit a target are going to cause them to bleed out anyways --- just not in a fashion that immediately incapacitates them. The bulk of the mass of an arm or leg is also where you're most likely to hit a huge artery.

* You shoot the legs of an armed attacker and you've left their arms and hands functional. Which means that the option (which doesn't really exist but stipulate that it does) to fire at the legs is situational; maybe it's something you could do with an attacker some distance away from the victim and carrying a hammer, but it would be totally ineffective against a target with a gun. You want rules that work in all situations.

* Assuming optimal conditions in a police shooting incident is silly, because everyone involved in that situation is completely and unavoidably overloaded with adrenaline. Police are going to fire multiple times, even if the guidelines say otherwise. They are going to turn in their worst firearm performances, not their range performances, because they're impaired. Stipulating that, you want them picking the part of the target where they're most likely to hit what they're aiming at.

There are other less credible arguments against "shoot to wound". For instance: police are equipped with rounds designed to penetrate but then mostly be stopped by the mass of someone's chest and surrounding clothing, and those rounds won't be adequately impeded by an arm or a leg. Ok, so change the ammunition.