News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Many of the NSA’s Loudest Defenders Have Financial Ties t... by lostcolony on Friday May 15, 2015 @09:49AM (#9550510)
The problem is the process is innately corrupt though. If we wanted an uncorrupted process, we would set aside tax money to pay researchers in the field grants solely to study and advise, with laws preventing them from taking subsidies and the like elsewhere. Perhaps with a process to allocate existing researchers to new issues. Corporation feels that we need more spying on our citizens because it makes them profitable? They could raise that issue, an existent researcher could look into it; but the continued funding of that researcher is not tied to their findings or results in any way.

As it is, the side with the most money gets the most lobbying, and that's not even considering the negative effect of campaign donations and the like.

Re:Many of the NSA’s Loudest Defenders Have Financial Ties t... by aeturnum on Friday May 15, 2015 @12:55PM (#9551893)
> we would set aside tax money to pay researchers in the field grants solely to study and advise

Just because someone works for the government does not make them free from political influence. [0]

I'm not happy with our current system, but I'm also dismayed by all the people who think it has a simple solution.

[0] http://www.bloomberg.com/politics/articles/2015-03-08/florid...

Re:Many of the NSA’s Loudest Defenders Have Financial Ties t... by shit_parade2 on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:18AM (#9550711)
Lobbying is an inheritly tricky problem because you want to allow everyone to exercise free speech, if suddenly only government funded researchers are allowed to make comments on policy you no longer can participate in democratic governance.

The problem is governents have way too much control over nearly every facet of the economy and it is much cheaper and easier to buy a senator and get some new regulations passed than it is to build a successful product or service that everyday people want to opt in for.

When you mandate decisions, you tend to get bad and corrupt decisions that benefit the few over the many.

Re:Many of the NSA’s Loudest Defenders Have Financial Ties t... by fineman on Friday May 15, 2015 @03:52PM (#9553210)
It's not the issue of the speech in lobbying, it's that lobbying in politics means gifts of money.

I can "lobby" a police officer not to give me a ticket, but when I offer him a $20 all of a sudden he'll call it a bribe and slap the cuffs on me. (Despite my explanations that money is speech, and thus protected...)

Re:Many of the NSA’s Loudest Defenders Have Financial Ties t... by mathiasben on Friday May 15, 2015 @11:46AM (#9551344)
The congressional research service does this. Unfortunatley over the last two decades it's been crippled by partisian meddling. - http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/magazine/januaryfebruary_20...