News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by fweespeech on Friday May 15, 2015 @09:47AM (#9550493)
> Basically the only reason most people struggle financially in the US is due to their own financial illiteracy and living above their means. If you manage not to fall victim to either of those then you can save a substantial portion of your income towards a very early retirement should you choose to do so.

That is really only true for households above the median income.

So "most" is not a factual statement. About half of the country can save [at most] a few thousand dollars a year unless they want to ruin their health and take other risks that are essentially gambling.

That is part of what pisses me off about /r/financialindependence. Alot of the "suggestions" those people make are essentially gambling. [e.g. going without proper insurance coverage, high risk investments if you cannot save much due to income, eat unhealthy to save money which will cost you later] Or they assume you are making $60k a year so you can save $20k/year. You can't save $20k/year if you are making $30k.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by Omniusaspirer on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:07AM (#9550635)
If you can only save a few thousand a year then you fall firmly into the "living above their means" category in my personal opinion. Having children you cannot afford is a common way that lower income people live above their means, even if it sounds crass to word it in that way.

My anecdotal experience working alongside lower class workers is that most of them run into trouble through trying to live a middle class lifestyle without the income to support it. They buy new cars, they eat out often, they refuse to work more than 40 hrs/wk, and they live in pricier apartments without roommates. All of these mistakes tie into the financial illiteracy that plagues people who were never exposed to those with good money habits.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by dionidium on Friday May 15, 2015 @11:21AM (#9551172)
> Having children you cannot afford is a common way that lower income people live above their means

Poor people will never stop having sex, or wanting kids, or desiring a drink at the end of the day, because it just so happens that you don't lose basic human desires when you're poor. A lot of talk about financial literacy is really just moralizing about behaviors the lecturer would never dream of giving up himself.

It's a dead-end conversation, because, again, humans are always going to do the stuff that humans do.

But this entire thread is doomed because it stems from a claim that most people who struggle do so because they're living above their means. It seems to me that most people who struggle do so because they don't have as much money as the people who don't struggle.

EDIT: Dear HN, can we make > start a quote, already? Look at how many people in this thread alone have used it in that way! I do it all the time and usually edit it back out.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by zzalpha on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:24AM (#9550763)
Or, alternatively: the erosion of wages in the face of rising inflation has placed a reasonable lifestyle out of the reach of many people. No longer can a household function on a single income while owning a home and raising a couple kids. Unfortunately society demands such a lifestyle from folks in order to be deemed a "success" and so people life beyond their now eroded means because they only alternative is to give up the dream they were sold every time someone opined about the "American Dream".

Of course the alternative view is to blame these folks and tacitly assume that the right to a comfortable lifestyle with a couple kids is a luxury only for the rich.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by Omniusaspirer on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:32AM (#9550826)
I don't mean to assert this is an optimal scenario, but it is the one we've all been placed in. What choice do we really have but to try and live according to the circumstances we were born into?
Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by TheOtherHobbes on Friday May 15, 2015 @11:38AM (#9551291)
>What choice do we really have but to try and live according to the circumstances we were born into?

We can also work to change those circumstances for future generations.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by Kalium on Friday May 15, 2015 @04:09PM (#9553338)
How about we admit to ourselves that the "American Dream" lifestyle was only workable because most of the rest of the first world was a series of smoking craters? It's not sustainable going forward. It's not a sane goal. Abandon it. Reshape our goals around what can be reasonably accomplished.
Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by fweespeech on Friday May 15, 2015 @03:46PM (#9553176)
> If you can only save a few thousand a year then you fall firmly into the "living above their means" category in my personal opinion.

The living wage project from MIT is designed to be the minimum viable estimate with no savings and living paycheck to paycheck.

http://livingwage.mit.edu/counties/06037

$23,640/year

http://livingwage.mit.edu/places/1308904000

$21,007/year

http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/cpstables/032011/perinc/new01...

http://livingwage.mit.edu/places/1324504204

> $17,640

Btw, Augusta, Georgia is literally one of the 10 cheapest cities [and if you read the Household Income as a "well they can do it!", remember the living wage is a single adult, two adults is double and they can't again]:

http://www.kiplinger.com/slideshow/real-estate/T006-S001-10-...

~36% of the population is below the living wage number in major metro areas.

52.16% make less than $30,000.00

> My anecdotal experience working alongside lower class workers is that most of them run into trouble through trying to live a middle class lifestyle without the income to support it. They buy new cars, they eat out often, they refuse to work more than 40 hrs/wk, and they live in pricier apartments without roommates. All of these mistakes tie into the financial illiteracy that plagues people who were never exposed to those with good money habits.

> The basic framework of early retirement is pretty simple: cut way down on your spending, then invest your savings. High savings rates can lead to surprisingly fast retirements. For example, if you save half your income, you'll be ready to retire in around 17 years.

http://www.vox.com/2015/5/1/8518455/extreme-early-retirement

The majority of the population can't save half of their income like Mr Money Mustache and other FI people suggest.

It isn't even mathematically possible for most of the country.

Your moralizing is proof you are ignorant and don't have a real argument.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by Omniusaspirer on Friday May 15, 2015 @05:19PM (#9553738)
I like the personal attack at the end.

The figures given by the living wage calculator are assuming a middle class lifestyle which is obviously ignorant when discussing lower class economics. Plugging in my own city of Ann Arbor, Michigan gives wildly inflated figures that fall in line exactly with my claims up above. The rent figure given is for having your own one bedroom apartment with no roommates, the food figure is hilariously overstated ($242/month), transportation assumes a pretty new car or very long commutes ($306/month). These figures simply are not realistic for a lower class individual.

I am living a lower class lifestyle right now as I type this. I live in a shared home with 2 other people. I drive an older but reliable car I purchased for $2.2k cash (a luxury expense, I could have kept taking the bus/biking to work). I rarely eat out, and I avoid expensive items at the grocery store barring a few healthy choices like nuts. I split a $45/month 50 mbit internet connection with both my roommates. No cable. $30/month cell phone bill (another luxury). I have health and auto insurance.

Overall, I have a pretty comfortable life for less than <$10k/yr. Nothing is stopping genuinely poor people from doing the same except extraordinary misfortunes (birth defects, severe disabilities). There is no moralizing here, just the cold hard numbers and experience from someone actually living this life and interacting daily with others at the bottom of the workforce.

EDIT:

After seeing your comment above I want to point out that at no point did I assert you could retire by 30 years old on this kind of income. If you're trying to argue that point then it's a strawman. I will also add that if you're still making ~20k/yr all of your life then you've made some financial mistakes in regards to your actual career choices, even janitorial staff end up around 35k/yr after a while.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by fweespeech on Friday May 15, 2015 @05:59PM (#9553932)
Okay, so your argument is you know better than a professor at MIT who studies this stuff.

K.

You may want to consider:

1) If I had to rely on a bus/bike for work, I would not have a job.

2) If I did have a reliable cell phone with data capable of providing a wifi hotspot in an emergency, I would not have a job.

3) If I did not have a solid internet connection, I would not have a job.

A number of things you claim are luxuries, really are not luxuries if you want to be employed in a number of fields. Even the guy that does the basic helpdesk stuff needs that and he only is paid $30k a year.

You also are ignoring one-off costs like repairs and medical costs when you quote these numbers and thump your chest. I have annual medical costs [beyond insurance] of 10% of your claimed spending. For fuck's sake.

http://www.nasdaq.com/article/mcdonalds-sample-budget-sheet-...

http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/07/mcdonald...

> McDonald's Can't Figure Out How Its Workers Survive on Minimum Wage

Hell, even the McDonald's Sample Budget everyone calls a joke has over $12,000 in annual expenses.

http://livingwage.mit.edu/places/2616103000

> The rent figure given is for having your own one bedroom apartment with no roommates

> I am living a lower class lifestyle right now as I type this. I live in a shared home with 2 other people.

$649 is the housing budget including utilities, cleaning supplies, and all other related expenses not just rent.

https://annarbor.craigslist.org/sha/5024320646.html - $500 https://annarbor.craigslist.org/hou/5025045124.html - $400 https://annarbor.craigslist.org/sha/5024006969.html - $400

Yeah, these people are renting one bedrooms. Sure buddy. $400+money for utilities,etc. puts them safely within the $649 budget and they aren't renting one bedroom apartments now are they?

I honestly don't even believe you at this point because you are clearly oblivious to the going rental rate in your own f'n city.

> EDIT: After seeing your comment above I want to point out that at no point did I assert you could retire by 30 years old on this kind of income. If you're trying to argue that point then it's a strawman. I will also add that if you're still making ~20k/yr all of your life then you've made some financial mistakes in regards to your actual career choices, even janitorial staff end up around 35k/yr after a while.

You support the prevailing view of /r/FinancialIndependence and their idols who make claims about retiring in their 30s like that.

That isn't a strawman and I quoted an article where they did exactly that. How am I supposed to read your mind and realize the very group you chose to use as a benchmark to discuss:

> If you manage not to fall victim to either of those then you can save a substantial portion of your income towards a very early retirement should you choose to do so.

Maybe you should be more specific then rather than cry strawman when those FI folks talking about "very early retirement", its retirement in their 30s.

Cry strawman if you want but by the standards of the community you were talking about, 30s is what that phrase means and I can point to a ton of posts/blogs in relation to that group of people.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by Omniusaspirer on Friday May 15, 2015 @07:00PM (#9554201)
Ann Arbor is one of the most expensive cities in the entire state of Michigan and is often compared to places like Boulder, Colorado. Most lower class individuals would live somewhat in its periphery, almost certainly not adjacent to the UofM campus or downtown. I personally pay $440/month with utilities included and I've seen many places become available in the 2 years I've been here at similar prices. Like everywhere it takes some patience and planning to get a good deal- this is par for the course for anyone looking to minimize expenses. Poor planning is expensive. If you choose not to believe this that's fine, but I have zero reason to lie.

Even paying a bit more on rent a roommate scenario with split utilities is never going to add up to $675 a month if you're at all savvy and modest in the residence you choose.

If your job requires a car and phone but doesn't pay an amount that allows you to afford those things then you should get a different job. $40/month will get you unlimited everything phone wise, or if like me you rarely call then you can do T-Mobiles $30 a month 5gb 4g plan w/ 100 calling minutes.

I'm in no way trying to thump my chest here, I'm trying to provide a detailed look at this lifestyle within the overall context of FI's ideas regarding saving and well planned finances. I also apologize if I somehow led you to believe I was saying anyone regardless of circumstance and income could retire at 30.

I'm genuinely a little puzzled as to why you're going at me so aggressively, would you mind going into your own lifestyle and why you feel I must be lying to you?

EDIT: As far as being mad I wasn't more specific, pay some mind to the demographic that visits this site. I would be surprised if even 1 in 10,000 visitors to this site will never in their life have a job paying more than ~20k/yr (assuming they live in the 1st world). My message was obviously directed at this sites prevailing demographic.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by kidsthesedays on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:08AM (#9550636)
I agree that most is silly. Certainly many though.

Consider: When I was single I lived a very very very comfortable life on $22,000 a year (cash, not income). I put that much in my checking account and everything else in savings and investment. This was after I spent several years putting the majority of my pay on loans to become debt free and paid off the $60,000 in student loans and a very small car loan.

If someone makes a salary of $30,000 a year than they probably take home around $22,000 after taxes and insurance. It would be much less comfortable for them to have a lot of savings. True, not impossible, but much much harder than me since their takehome pay is equal to my "frugal" pay. They would have to give up much more than I do. Obviously you can't max out your 401(k) and IRA on that salary, maxing those out would be more than your take home pay! Basically - not possible until you get past median income (which is around $50k)

As an aside I don't think children have to be that expensive... Granted I don't have them but I see all my friends spending a massive amount of money on very silly things for their kids. Nobody needs the majority of crap that is bought for kids. Household size has, IIR, doubled in the last 60 years. It isn't like kids' needs have changed to take up double space since my grandparents were raising them - it is parents just give them more.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by fweespeech on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:41AM (#9550915)
> If someone makes a salary of $30,000 a year than they probably take home around $22,000 after taxes and insurance. It would be much less comfortable for them to have a lot of savings. True, not impossible, but much much harder than me since their takehome pay is equal to my "frugal" pay. They would have to give up much more than I do. Obviously you can't max out your 401(k) and IRA on that salary, maxing those out would be more than your take home pay!

Yes, but the amount they'd save is "a few thousand a year". I doubt they'd save more than $3,000/year after the big expenses and random things happening [e.g. dental, medical]

You'd need around $1,000,000 to produce $30,000 a year [3% "safe return"] indefinitely.

http://www.bloomberg.com/personal-finance/calculators/401k/

You'd need to save for 35 years to retire before 60 [using the defaults, no employer match since you need access before you could access a IRA/401k, etc] which is what /r/financialindependence is about.

Mr Money Mustache and all of their idols retire early [by 40] and that is what they emphasize. That simply isn't possible on $30k/year in the US.

EDIT:

> Which was exactly my point. :)

Ah okay. I thought you were like the guy I was replying to who is completely 100% convinced that they can retire in their 30s like /r/FI aims for if they'd just "save more money".

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by kidsthesedays on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:53AM (#9551006)
Which was exactly my point. :)

You'd have to basically be homeless to save enough to be able to retire very early on a modest income such as $30,000.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by bigtunacan on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:52AM (#9550995)
There is no way around it; kids ARE expensive. The bulk cost of raising kids is not all of the unnecessary things, even with all of the crap kids have today compared to prior generations, that is all incidental costs.

The real costs of kids are the necessities. Child care, clothing, food, medical & dental expenses.

I live in the midwest and send/sent my children to a daycare that is extremely price conscious even for this area. It cost me over $7000 per year per child. So when I had 3 kids in day care at the same time; I was paying $21,000 a year just for daycare. For some people that is not sustainable; it is as much or more than they earn.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by kidsthesedays on Friday May 15, 2015 @11:21AM (#9551173)
This is what confuses me, when I was growing up there was poor kids childcare that I went to that was dirt cheap. Don't they exist anymore? Our (lower income) city offered free summer camp and I went to a variety of after school programs. Sure you can't do that with babies though (I don't think).

The vast majority of my clothes were hand-me-downs or thrift store or sometimes sales rack stuff. My mom and her sisters and brothers passed around garbage bags full of their kids' old clothes for the smaller kids and clothes were passed on to coworkers and friends. Several kids all wore clothes until they fell apart. I was allowed to have one pair of shoes (only from Payless) and I wore them either until they didn't fit or until the next schoolyear came. My parents didn't spend hardly anything at all on clothes.

Medical costs obviously are high (unless you are in the military)

I never even felt deprived or anything either. Not being able to pick out my clothes wasn't even a big issue for me.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by seestheday on Friday May 15, 2015 @03:58PM (#9553255)
What state/city? I'm assuming you live in the US. I live in Canada and I've never heard of a poor kids childcare of free summer camp paid for by the city even here.

People talking about saving money by not spending money on clothes and toys really don't know what they're talking about. Brand new clothes and toys today are super cheap compared to what they were when I was a kid. For example, I just bought some brand new baby shoes and shirts on sale for $2 at the grocery store. If I was poor it would cost me more in bus fare to get to the used clothing store than I would have saved had I just bought stuff new at the grocery store. The biggest cost for me _by_far_ is childcare and summer camps.

Re:The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work, and What They Do Instead by kidsthesedays on Friday May 15, 2015 @07:24PM (#9554278)
Maybe you gotta live in a low income area. I went to the YMCA, YWCA, Boys and Girls Club, some place that is run by a couple nuns and sponsored by a charity... I think we may have gotten subsidies from somewhere though? Honestly I am not sure, I just know that they were cheap and that's where all the poor kids went (including me).

These places were pretty friggin boring though, just a bunch of sitting around doing not much of anything except playing with yarn with minimal supervision.

The "free camp" (as we called it) was especially boring.