News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A book on the persistence of elites is an unexpected guid... by rayiner on Thursday May 14, 2015 @05:33PM (#9547705)
That doesn't actually make any sense. If 100 people can do the job, why pick the people you like the most instead of the ones who are willing to work for the least? Why filter it down to 10 people based on pointless criteria and then pay them all a bunch of money? You're essentially assuming that professional services firms are irrational.

The reason these firms don't screen for knowledge is that they don't care what you know, they care what you can be taught. These are fields where you can't learn the job without actually doing the job, and where relative skill often matters more than absolute skill.

Re:A book on the persistence of elites is an unexpected guid... by lordnacho on Thursday May 14, 2015 @05:55PM (#9547812)
1) Signalling. Look at my fantastic management consultancy. All my people have Ivy League degrees.

2) These people are (In Thiel's words) indefinite optimists. They don't know what they want. They could do anything. There's plenty of other boring jobs they could do. You have to pay up. By contrast, iOS dev guy needs an app company.

3) A lot of these firms run pseudo-monopolies. It costs a LOT of money to get a bank license. There's only 4 big 4 firms left, and you can't have Mickey Mouse as your auditor. The magic circle is not getting bigger. Monopoly profits means you can pay over the odds. You can have a hiring strategy that is basically just a burnout factory. More hamsters will come.

Re:A book on the persistence of elites is an unexpected guid... by exelius on Thursday May 14, 2015 @05:36PM (#9547723)
Because they hire for likability for a reason. If the client likes your people, and your people are good at talking to people, the client will be more likely to hire them.

Professional services margins are already so huge (think 200-500%) that what you pay your employees is almost irrelevant to the bottom line. Thus, these careers are highly lucrative and usually pay 10-20% more than the exact same job in industry.