News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nate Silver on the Leaked Global Warming Emails by fauigerzigerk on Saturday November 21, 2009 @03:47AM (#954363)
Nate Silver is right. This says absolutely nothing about global warming itself. It says something about how scientific research and academia work.

They are in a gold rush. As long as the climate change debate remains top of the agenda the money will keep on coming. Securing continued funding for their projects is the main and sometimes only concern of scientists. At least that is what I conclude from many years of working with them.

They are funded by politicians and other sources that will dry up once the global global warming hype ends. What politicians need is a clear and unambiguous picture that speaks truth beyond reasonable doubt. That's what politicians will pay climate scientists for and that's what they are struggling so hard to deliver.

All this is completely without connection to the question of climate change proper.

Re:Nate Silver on the Leaked Global Warming Emails by jswinghammer on Saturday November 21, 2009 @06:34AM (#954449)
That's what politicians will pay climate scientists for and that's what they are struggling so hard to deliver.

Doesn't this imply that there is a major conflict of interest here and that the whole science should be labeled suspect by default? I think most people will give the bosses whatever they want even if it isn't true.

Re:Nate Silver on the Leaked Global Warming Emails by fauigerzigerk on Saturday November 21, 2009 @07:55AM (#954493)
No doubt there is a major conflict of interest. But there are other forces at play as well that mitigate the issue. Scientists are obviously concerned about their name, so outright lying is probably rare.

Making things appear clearer than they actually are, hiding stuff that is inconclusive, writing project proposals opportunistically according to where the money is, these are the things that happen all the time.

And I'm not talking specifically about climate research, but about the driving forces of research and research funding in europe.

Re:Nate Silver on the Leaked Global Warming Emails by Locke1689 on Saturday November 21, 2009 @06:02AM (#954424)
Securing continued funding for their projects is the main and sometimes only concern of scientists. At least that is what I conclude from many years of working with them.

Data is not the plural of anecdote. In addition I find it insulting that you would attempt to negatively characterize an entire field which you have no knowledge of. In fact, this comment is so unbelievable that I would like to know where and who you worked with.

Re:Nate Silver on the Leaked Global Warming Emails by fauigerzigerk on Saturday November 21, 2009 @07:25AM (#954478)
I'm in europe. Maybe that gives you some peace of mind.
Re:Nate Silver on the Leaked Global Warming Emails by pradocchia on Saturday November 21, 2009 @11:30AM (#954651)
Ha! I doubt it's much different in the US.