In real life no one will notice the difference. And the favicon is now flat without a bevel. That would have taken about 10 minutes.
Seems like a lot of work for nothing in the wordmark change.
In addition to helping implement the brand in the short term across teams and products, a redesign like this also gives the brand a clear foundation on which to grow and evolve, instead of being fragmented.
A huge part of being a designer in a large company comes down to figuring out how to design systems. The impact of adjusting 4px probably did occur in 10 min in a design program. But the conversations and thought that went into the overall system took far far longer and required a huge amount of knowledge of how systems like this are used and implemented.
It's a very subconscious thing, how we appreciate two similar things with slight changes, and often we would struggle to explain why we feel that way. It just 'feels' better.
Unless you're on the design team for a large company, it's easy to forget that other people use assets differently and you can't just copy and paste something from a hackathon poster into something that appears on the marketing website.
The thought that goes into changes like this is deep and complex. It's also not glamorous nor does it get prioritized often. Great write up.
[0] http://officeofbenbarry.com/images/portfolio/1200/benbarry-0...