News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by ghshephard on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @12:49PM (#9540222)
I realize Microsoft has to price segment, which requires they call out an "Enterprise" category for Mobile and Laptop/Desktop, but sometimes I wonder if they really need all of these categories.

For example, do they really get significant financial value from having a Windows 10 Home, Windows 10 Education, Windows 10 Pro? particularly as they are offering it as a free upgrade to Windows 7/8 users.

Notice they don't have a Windows 10 Mobile Home, Windows 10 Mobile Education, and Windows 10 Mobile Pro - just plain, "Windows 10 Mobile".

My suspicion is they would have managed to avoid customer confusion, and captured pretty much all the same economic value, with a simple list of:

  Windows 10
  Windows 10 Mobile
  Windows 10 Enterprise
  Windows 10 Mobile Enteprise
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by sonnyz on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:00PM (#9540313)
I agree. A simple "Windows 10" with no subtitle would really make things easier for the consumer. Appending 'Home' on what is really a feature reduced version of Windows 10 doesn't seem to be in the best interest of the customer.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by wernercd on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:26PM (#9540515)
Define "Feature Reduced"? Lack of Domain? HyperV? Remote Desktop options?

What features are people "losing" with Home that 95% of "Home" users "need"?

Sure... You and I can't live without half of those things, but home users generally won't notice - or care - if HyperV is missing.

You pay more for Pro/Enterprise because it has added features that Power Users/Businesses need.

Glass Half Empty/Full... Potato/Patato... Home isn't feature reduced... Pro is feature added. Enterprise is feature complete.

If you want feature reduced... look into versions like Starter Edition - http://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/windows_7-w...

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by bad_user on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:54PM (#9540702)
Full-disk encryption is something people want even if they don't realize it. Android, iOS, OS X and Linux have encryption built in, whereas BitLocker for Windows comes with the Pro version only.

Normal people also want Remote Desktop, again, even if they don't realize it. That's how I'm able to debug the problems that my parents are having, from a distance.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by ZoFreX on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:47PM (#9541122)
> Full-disk encryption is something people want even if they don't realize it.

Really? Because it has very limited security advantages, and very real performance impact on many systems. Android L came with it enabled by default and it cut performance in half on devices that weren't designed for it.

And why would Joe Public want it? This is something with so many caveats that DPR, a paranoid computer expert with quite a lot to hide, gained no protection from it whatsoever. So what are the odds a regular user will use it correctly and benefit from it?

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by bad_user on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @03:19PM (#9541319)
I think you're wrong on multiple counts ...

1) it has real security advantages, because your PC or device is a single point of failure - lose your (unencrypted) device and the thief can gain access to everything, including your email account, your facebook, your bank account, etc... and for example AES-256 with a good enough password is unbreakable.

2) On the desktop if you have an Intel processor with the AES-NI instructions set, then you won't notice a speed hit. Core i5 is such a processor. And I own a Nexus 6 device that came encrypted by default, never felt sluggish and I have it filled with music, games, presentations and maps.

3) I don't know whom DPR is, however in the US people are protected against key disclosure with the fifth amendment. Of course, the technology is relatively new and the fifth has yet to be proven in court against key disclosure, however there are cases in which this constitutional right has been upheld [1]. And while in many countries you may not be able to resist a court order, you may be able to resist unwarranted searches or seizures; which is still useful, because ...

4) Most people have something to hide and that's undeniable. Even if you're willing to fully cooperate with the authorities, it is undeniable that most public workers are incompetents. So placing your trust in such individuals is very dangerous for one's self being. Let me give you an example ... because of an incompetent public worker, my personal identification details and home address ended up in a local newspaper. That's how identities can be stoles and lifes can be ruined, OK?

Now - do you really want to place your trust, your data (like 10 years old pictures, emails describing your love affairs, search history describing your most secret desires, etc..) into the hands of such people? You'd have to be a fool to wish for this. At least wait for the FBI to come ;-)

5) I'm sick and tired of the "Joe Public" fallacy. People are really not that dumb.

[1] https://www.eff.org/press/releases/appeals-court-upholds-con...

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by ZoFreX on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @03:46PM (#9541484)
1) "AES-256 with a good enough password is unbreakable" is a provably incorrect statement. AES-256 used in ECB mode for example is incredibly breakable. And the modes available to you in FDE are compromises compared to what you would use for encrypting data in flight.

2) Windows is aiming for supporting a lot more than just powerful x86 CPUs though. You implied everyone wants this, not just people with CPUs with AES-NI instructions.

3&4&5) DPR = The guy who ran the silk road. So he had a lot more to hide than most people and was a lot more competent than most people but FDE didn't help him at all. It wasn't key disclosure - his computer was seized while it was still running. I don't think people are all that dumb. I think you need to be very very smart to fully understand the compromises involved with FDE, and if you're that smart you'll rely on something else entirely for the data most important to you.

I also think a lot of people, given the choice between "your data is sort of protected against theft, as long as the system is actually off not just suspended, and assuming you used a strong password" and "your data can be easily recovered when you hose your system and/or forget your password" would pick the latter.

A small side-note regarding key disclosure: not everyone is in the USA. Where I live, it's absolutely definitive that I hand over keys on request or I go to jail :(

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by veidr on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @10:21PM (#9543130)
Device theft by a non-technical perpetrator is incredibly common.

Even just to mitigate against this single specific threat, full-disk encryption on a modern PC is completely worth it, for soccer moms, grandparents and hackers alike.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by ZoFreX on Thursday May 14, 2015 @11:43AM (#9545785)
And wiping the device and immediately fencing it is also incredibly common. No-one's going to hijack your Facebook and steal your wedding photos.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by epistasis on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:53PM (#9540701)
Remote Desktop is almost essential for "home" users, as it allows remote guidance through the computer.

>You pay more for Pro/Enterprise because it has added features that Power Users/Businesses need.

Do you really? When negotiating large licenses with volume discounts, does Microsoft really end up charging more for each install than they do with the Home options?

How many consumers pay for the Pro or Enterprise versions, and how much money does Microsoft actually make on that small price differential, compared to how much the market segmentation costs them in terms of consumer confusion and dismay?

Clearly MS knows these answers better than I do, but I also don't really trust their marketing teams to execute that well in the consumer space. Sure, they are awesome in the business sphere, but they really suck when it comes to consumers.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by tracker1 on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:38PM (#9541048)
Enterprise/Education will only be available through organization based license agreements... not really for individuals. As to Home/Pro, I mostly agree... I wouldn't mind seeing a base version that's effectively Pro... considering the domain is a server license with additional CALs required anyway (SAMBA aside).

That, or just sell the pro services as an upgrade package for windows, instead of a separate OS package... I know it's all in the details, just the same it can/should be more transparent.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by merb on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @03:44PM (#9541466)
Remote Desktop is not essential for "home" users, there is Windows Remote Assistance which is way better for that use case. It is based on RDP but can traversal NAT, so Remote Desktop is really not needed for "home" users at all.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by wvenable on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:00PM (#9540317)
The editions make sense for market segmentation. Home editions cannot join a domain so that rules them out for business and education. Then they want to price segment between schools and business which makes the distinction between Education and Enterprise.

Pro is sort of the consumer version of Enterprise; it can join a domain too. I run 8.1 pro, not because of the join a domain feature, but because it can host a remote desktop session and home cannot.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by arthurfm on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @06:15PM (#9542327)
> Home editions cannot join a domain so that rules them out for business and education.

The Home edition of Windows 10 sounds like it might be able to join Azure Active Directory. [1]

Support for modern form factors. Azure AD Join will work on devices that don't have the traditional domain join capabilities.

[1] http://blogs.technet.com/b/ad/archive/2015/05/13/azure-activ...

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by bskap on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @12:58PM (#9540293)
"Pro" is for people that don't have volume licenses but want the business-specific features like domain joining. Remember, Windows 10 may be a free upgrade, but it's not free and I imagine they still make quite a bit of extra money from businesses buying Pro.

"Education" looks like it's a discounted volume license available to schools. Not sure what extra features it's going to have but it's not something that anyone other than a school administrator will ever care about.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by Spooky23 on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:21PM (#9540484)
Education exists because Microsoft provides cheaper licensing to schools as a marketing exercise. They also let you buy the license entitlement through volume licensing, so smart schools will buy PCs with FreeDOS or Linux and BYO Windows.

This creates a problem, because the Federal government requires that it receives the lowest possible price for a particular product. So they carve out the education market as a separate SKU.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by stephengillie on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:02PM (#9540325)
I can't tell you how many times I've had coworkers come in with a new device they convinced management to buy them, without my approval, and they've saved a few hundred on the OS by having a Personal edition.

So MS is paid twice there - once for the Personal version that came with the device, and once again for the business buying a single copy of Pro version to install over the Personal version.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by daigoba66 on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:05PM (#9540357)
Businesses (large ones anyway) tend to buy Windows Enterprise which only available through volume licensing. Technically the free upgrade is not available for Win7 or Win8 Enterprise (fine print on this page: http://windows.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-10/about). But if the organization always pays for Software Assurance, that includes upgrades for all covered licenses.

In my experience I see smaller businesses just purchasing hardware with OEM licenses (usually Pro).

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by mreiland on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @04:36PM (#9541782)
Does Windows 7 Pro upgrade to Windows 10 Pro?
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by grandalf on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:23PM (#9540492)
> My suspicion is they would have managed to avoid customer confusion, and captured pretty much all the same economic value, with a simple list of:

You are probably right, but doing so would have cost MS a significant amount of money. This is an entrenched company trying to avoid killing so many cash cows.

Likely the biggest motivation for this segmentation/pricing strategy is profit extraction from existing, business customers.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by iamthepieman on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:16PM (#9540443)
I run 8.1 pro on my personal PCs because I need hyper-v and remote desktop for development. I would be happy to buy a "home" edition if it came with the those features but MS captured my additional dollars for the pro edition precisely because I did need them.

Most people are getting OEM editions of Windows anyways. Anyone installing an OS on bare hardware is not going to be put off by confusion between SKUs.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by sp332 on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:18PM (#9540460)
It's only free as an upgrade, and even that is time-limited. New copies will still cost money.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by ikeboy on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:28PM (#9540529)
What seems to be new in this announcement is that if you do upgrade for free, you get that for life. Before it wasn't clear if you'd need to pay subscription fees afterwards.

Plus, you can still get retail Win7 DVDs at under $100, then upgrade for free to Win10 Pro.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by sp332 on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:35PM (#9540568)
Right, but if you don't upgrade in the first year then you might not get it for free. I don't think anyone has said how much it will cost exactly. I haven't heard of a subscription fee either?
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by 33W on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @12:56PM (#9540272)
Agreed. I would only add to it their embedded "IoT" version.