Secondly, as wasteful as our current financial system is, it doesn't seem to have that strong growth factor built in. Making and maintaining bitcoins depends on ever increasing energy use; energy, which is wasted in the most literal sense - burned out on nonsense computations just to show that you had enough of it to burn.
I think we should treat the energy used on financial system as upkeep - unavoidable cost we have to pay because as a species, we suck at coordinating, but that we'd do best to minimize.
Second, the energy used by bitcoin doesn't need to increase. The cost of all the energy used will tend towards the price of the subsidy+fees, and the subsidy is being phased out. In a few decades the subsidy will be almost gone.
If bitcoin completely replaced finance, would it really use more energy than saved by finance stopping?
And you didn't address the point about capturing the heat.
This is a painfully disingenuous response. It's obvious that the system servicing billions of people and businesses around the world would dwarf the energy tab of a system that services a relative handful of niche users. Why even bother with such a clearly flawed comparison?
> The cost of all the energy used will tend towards the price of the subsidy+fees, and the subsidy is being phased out. In a few decades the subsidy will be almost gone.
Yes, the subsidy will drop but the energy costs will continue to rise and the fees will obviously have to rise to compensate for the absence of subsidies (otherwise the miners will be losing money).
> If bitcoin completely replaced finance, would it really use more energy than saved by finance stopping?
Finance will never "stop". Demand for consumer financial services (like banks, loans, credit & debit cards, etc) would remain pretty much the same, even with bitcoin at the core of finance. The cost of "mining" dollars is negligible compared to the ancillary financial services that people actually care about, so replacing dollars with bitcoin simply adds the extra energy of bitcoin mining into the mix. If bitcoin were cheaper than the legacy system, then why is it that all bitcoin companies prefer to use "offchain transactions" (aka non-bitcoin transactions) whenever possible? The answer is that the blockchain is incredibly inefficient compared to the legacy financial system. Payment gateways like bitpay that have no choice but to interact with the blockchain have spent lots of money building trusted node networks in order to roll their own double-spend detection heuristics because relying on bitcoin's inherent security is too slow for the needs of an actual business. The only problem bitcoin solves is "decentralized" which isn't a problem for most people.
2. Why will energy costs continue to rise? If it becomes less profitable to mine, less mining happens, and less energy is used. This has happened in the past, when the price dropped.
3. Why are companies using off-chain transactions? It's faster for same-company transfers. In a sense, many banks are using "off dollar" transactions as well, not actual dollars. Sending bitcoin is still faster than sending money.
There are plenty of problems bitcoin solves. Just look at all the big-name companies using it, like NASDAQ, for example.
RE capturing heat - heat is a low-grade form of energy and electricity is high-grade. You can't power a machine from heat at efficiency levels of electricity. And if you want an electric heater, buy a heat pump - these run at 500% (!) electric to thermal conversion efficiency (by using 1kW of electricity to move 5kW of heat around).
https://blockchain.info/charts/hash-rate?showDataPoints=fals...
As you can see, the increase in hash rate has been stagnating for nearly a year at this point.
Also, how much energy does the legacy finance system waste? All the energy spent to build banks, armored trucks, secured networks, etc.
A couple years back they spent a couple hundred million to build a cable connecting New York and London for financial data because it was 5 milliseconds faster than what they had before.