I've only been at ones that work. I don't see how you could ask these questions and have it be a time sink: https://www.scrumalliance.org/community/articles/2014/april/...
>> What went well during the sprint cycle? >> What went wrong during the sprint cycle? >> What could we do differently to improve?
I have had Agile Evangelists, who are supposed to be good at making this stuff streamlined, turn around and say "Everyone needs to come up with five things in each category, then we'll go through and discuss them all, deciding on the most important things to change at the end"
In a team that was already too large (15ish people) I watched that eat an entire afternoon and produce no useful output on more than one occasion. In the team I was on (four, five?) it still seemed to take hours.
I know, I know, they were probably doing it all wrong, this is just my experience of one workplace.
I'm not saying it can't be done right, just that it doesn't seem to be a magic bullet and can devolve into navel-gazing.
A pretty important point for making scrum work, however, is aggressive timeboxing of everything. If you don't want retros to become a 4 hour developer-kvetch about somebody else's team, start by ruthlessly clipping it to 45 minutes.
I understand that this is not always an option in malfunctioning corporate environments; but Kanban/XP/programming motherfkerism wouldn't fly either in those situations.
When I rule the world, as they say, every meeting will contain only the people it needs to, "I don't feel this is relevant to my work or that I can contribute" will be the best reason not to attend and time limits will be aspirational in as much as everyone will aspire to beat them by as much as they can.
Unfortunately, as a contractor, I can suggest these things but not mandate them.
- A few people end up discussing some minor point only of interest to them while everyone else stares into space
- Every retrospective ends up being the same as the previous one: it's like someone recorded a meeting 2 years ago and plays it back every 8 weeks
- Things that went well are all internal; things that went badly are all other teams' fault (this can't always be true)
Yes, I realise those aren't really agile issues, just a symptom of having a relatively poorly defined meeting with lots of people.
Mostly the manager's minions and pets talk, generally in a softer tone more towards appreciation bordering sycophancy. The remaining fear to give any genuine feedback, fearing retribution. If some one does speak they are taken as non team players who will be handled appropriately the next raise/promotion cycle.
There fore no one talks.