What exactly should he have cited Solar Designer about? If you're going to criticize someone for not citing, and the citation isn't obvious, you should probably provide a link.
Are you referring to the key expansion property that Scott mentioned downthread? He cited the appropriate source: the HMAC specification. The properties he's talking about are obvious: the key is zero-padded to the block size and, if longer than the block size, hashed.
You're right. I'm specifically referring to his attacks.
I'm curious if you can find any references to the key expansion / hashing collision before Solar Designer started talking about it a little while ago.
If they're obvious you should be able to find dozens of references. Because they're obvious.
This took 15 seconds to find: https://eprint.iacr.org/2012/684.pdf
I stand corrected, there are in fact a decent number of people who mentioned HMAC(K,X)==HMAC(H(K),X) when len(K)>blocksize. So, you had no reason to cite Solar Designer and I shouldn't have implied you should. Sorry about that!
Still interested if you can find an earlier cite for HMAC collision. Most of what I find implies mad crypto cleverness, not this silly little construction.
You're correct that it went without saying in that people did not actually say it.
Way to not cite Solar Designer though.