Are we really? The social patterning is the religious revival meeting, and that's precisely the wrong way to frame science if you want to give outsider a realistic impression of what it means and how it works.
Pop-sci has a terrible flattening effect. It gives the public the mistaken impression that their opinion is worth as much as a professional's, because it's not so hard really after you've read about it in a cheap paperback.
It's the mindset of "evolution of just a theory" and "climate change scientists are only in it for the money" and "my opinion of string theory is just as valid as that of a PhD working at the Perimeter Institute of Princeton - and what is a perimeter anyway?"
I'm not suggesting we should return to the happy era of pipe-smoking public science paternalism of the 40s and 50s.
But the alternative meme - that's it's all just a point of view - is just as destructive and stupid.
Gladwell, Godin, TED, and the rest are enablers of that mindset, whether or not they agree with it personally.
Pop-sci has a terrible flattening effect. It gives the public the mistaken impression that their opinion is worth as much as a professional's, because it's not so hard really after you've read about it in a cheap paperback.
It's the mindset of "evolution of just a theory" and "climate change scientists are only in it for the money" and "my opinion of string theory is just as valid as that of a PhD working at the Perimeter Institute of Princeton - and what is a perimeter anyway?"
I'm not suggesting we should return to the happy era of pipe-smoking public science paternalism of the 40s and 50s.
But the alternative meme - that's it's all just a point of view - is just as destructive and stupid.
Gladwell, Godin, TED, and the rest are enablers of that mindset, whether or not they agree with it personally.