That, my friend, is a skill you can acquire and grow.
Since we're on the topic of popular science books, here's a reasonable read that can help you start improving:
http://www.amazon.com/Art-Thinking-Clearly-Rolf-Dobelli/dp/0...
But I don't think "clear thinking" is a solution to this problem. I can read a book and say "the facts as presented don't fit the narrative", which is what I did with paulsutter.
If I'm really dedicated, I can look up references. I can bypass the paywall, read a journal article, and see that the author has misrepresented the results.
But I can't read a book and say "wait, you're completely ignoring the effect that in-fighting in the Roman senate had on politics in Britain circa A.D. 50", because I don't know anything about that subject. I don't even know that it's relevant. Unknown unknowns.
I can't know everything, so I have to rely on other people.
That does perfectly identify the target market for Gladwell books.
> I stand by my interpretation. Gladwell's books aren't useful sources of knowledge, but they ARE a commercial gem. ... Maximum virality. It does sell a lot of books.
None of this means that Gladwell only cares about selling books.
*Readers might not care about X, but they might care about what critics think of a book. This makes sense: as a reader, I'm probably not capable of critically evaluating the arguments in a book, so I have to rely on critics to find out whether or not the arguments are solid.