News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:George Price, Who Tried to Prove Selflessness Doesn’t Exist by jessriedel on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @09:23AM (#9531528)
You're arguing for psychological egoism. The problem is that, although many acts of apparent selflessness have plausible selfish explanations, there are clearly some that don't. (People laying down in front of tanks, etc.)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychological_egoism#Criticism...

You either need to admit that some acts are selfless, or you end up just defining "what someone selfishly wants" as "what someone chooses to do", which isn't very useful.

Re:George Price, Who Tried to Prove Selflessness Doesn’t Exist by Lawtonfogle on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @11:17AM (#9532378)
>(People laying down in front of tanks, etc.)

There are a couple ways to handle this.

First, humans are not inherently rational. How many times does a human desire one goal but performs something that moves that goal further away from them, perhaps to the extent they destroy any hope of obtaining that goal?

Second, there are social benefits to selflessness that we will tend to be able to enjoy the benefits of but which are not always going to be there.

Consider a bird trained to press a button for food though the food only has a chance of being produced. Even in cases where there isn't food, the bird is still pressing the button to get food. Even when an outside observer knows the next press will not generate food, the bird is still pressing it for food. Even if we could inform the bird that food would not result from the next press, the bird would likely make the decision anyways to disregard our advice and press the button for the sake of food.