Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e...
by tome on Saturday November 21, 2009 @04:02AM
(#954371)
You're asking me how is a massively organised campaign participated in by thousands of people not educated specifically in your field different from defending your work against a critical colleague who happens to have his own pet theory?
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e...
by yummyfajitas on Saturday November 21, 2009 @09:37AM
(#954567)
It doesn't matter who the adversary is. If a flaw is found, the work is incorrect.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=952651
Sure, and if researchers are being forced to draw the line higher than usual due to external pressure from highly funded deniers, whose fault is that?
EDIT: Besides, if we define the adversary to be somebody making legitimate critical analyses of your data and models and showing up flaws in them, isn't dealing with that meant to be part of a scientists job? How different is it in practice to defending your work against criticism from other, supposedly more respectable, scientists?
It's ridiculous to claim that a lack of resources is a valid reason for intentionally hiding data from people with the skill to perform an adversarial analysis on it. If a scientist can't defend his results against Steve McIntyre, it means his results are indefensible. The person doesn't matter; the data, and its integrity, do.