YC partners do dozens of events every year in the US and dozens more in the rest of the world to reach out to people we don't have any connection to.
A great idea, product, market, traction, etc. will always carry more weight than anything else. As much as there is any single secret to YC's success (other than not having a coworking space), being willing to talk to people with no connection to us is it.
That said, we definitely take note of recommendations from YC founders about great people they've worked with, and we should be upfront about that.
Also, we think announcing this will help YC companies recruit, and anything we can do to help YC companies we like to do.
Why should YC care about your perception problems?
You have 5 applicants. They all look great/same. One of them has a reference you can trust. OF COURSE you weigh that. Why wouldn't you use a signal if you thought it might make a difference?
The fix from the applicants side isn't to try to put that in your resume (it's just a nice to have, hardly worth the X years it will take out of you life).
The fix is to differentiate yourself in terms of product and traction because that's the only way completely within your control.
ps: I agree with the general gist of your comment though :)
I not saying YC is elitist, because the since-the-beginning action of actually reading ALL applications, no matter from who, says a lot about the meaning to accept people with no connection at all to YC ecossystem.
But, said that, this announced action is a step on the opposite direction. I would appreciate another step in the direction of "we give a fair chance to not well connected people". Maybe some active recruiting actions on other places outside Silicon Valley.
As a double counter-example, 500startups do a lot of active recruiting outside USA. But, at least in Brazil, to have a real chance on getting in, you need the personal approval of a particular individual (Beddy Yang) to endorse your application. Having an application from Brazil, with no endorsement from this person, is as good as not applying at all. So solve one problem, but creating another to the openness of the selection process.