Re:Matrix HiFi – Blind testing high end full equipment
by mindslight on Monday May 11, 2015 @12:40PM
(#9526003)
I've come to realize there is a good amount of inherent subjectivity with respect to speakers - spatial dispersion isn't something that can be easily quantified, and as you say is going to vary significantly based on the room. So it kind of makes sense that listening tests are the only way to compare.
But for amplifiers, it seems that THD, frequency response, and phase response would capture everything you need to know to fully characterize the component. What else is there?
It's also odd to me that reviewers will sum up their conclusions as a piece of gear being "bright" or "bassy" - isn't that just an EQ setting? It seems that frequency response isn't really an important part of device characteristics since it can always be compensated for (within the physical limits of the driver), while the non-adjustable parts of response are (like, do speakers even give THD specs?). I would think a better methodology would be to use a reference microphone to calibrate the entire amplitude response to flat (or the reviewer's preference), and subjectivize from there.
Then again, a large part of the industry seems to be based around convincing people to spend 10x and try out several pieces of gear (pre-qualifying the price to themselves on their favorite), so I don't expect straight objectivity will ever be a high priority.
But for amplifiers, it seems that THD, frequency response, and phase response would capture everything you need to know to fully characterize the component. What else is there?
It's also odd to me that reviewers will sum up their conclusions as a piece of gear being "bright" or "bassy" - isn't that just an EQ setting? It seems that frequency response isn't really an important part of device characteristics since it can always be compensated for (within the physical limits of the driver), while the non-adjustable parts of response are (like, do speakers even give THD specs?). I would think a better methodology would be to use a reference microphone to calibrate the entire amplitude response to flat (or the reviewer's preference), and subjectivize from there.
Then again, a large part of the industry seems to be based around convincing people to spend 10x and try out several pieces of gear (pre-qualifying the price to themselves on their favorite), so I don't expect straight objectivity will ever be a high priority.