Re:More Consensus on Coffee’s Benefits Than You Might Think
by kenbellows on Monday May 11, 2015 @11:49AM
(#9525592)
It could be considered an ad hominem attack on a study if OP had said "the source was funded by coffee sellers and therefore it's all false and incorrect". But that's not what's happening here anyway.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:More Consensus on Coffee’s Benefits Than You Might Think
by josefresco on Monday May 11, 2015 @12:16PM
(#9525819)
The OP is "implying" that based on who funded the research, this may be truthful. So while the claim was not made outright, it was insinuated.
Re:More Consensus on Coffee’s Benefits Than You Might Think
by afarrell on Monday May 11, 2015 @12:38PM
(#9525992)
If the strength of an argument depends partly on trusting the integrity of a source, why is doubting that integrity a fallacy?
In an ideal world you judge experimental results by their reproducibility, but who on HN has the time to reproduce results?
Re:More Consensus on Coffee’s Benefits Than You Might Think
by kenbellows on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @07:58AM
(#9531033)
If all you are doing is casting reasonable doubt, that's fine. The logical fallacy arises when you point to the source of a proposition and declare that mouth that spoke it makes it false by nature. There's a big difference between "This pro-coffee study was funded by Big Coffee, so I'm skeptical and would like further studies and independent verification" and "This pro-coffee study was funded by Big Coffee, therefore the conclusion is false and coffee actually isn't good for you." Even if Big Coffee funded this report and benefited from its conclusions, the conclusions may very well still be valid; it would be a fallacy to reject this possibility outright.