Re:Google Map Maker will be temporarily unavailable for editing
by rmc on Monday May 11, 2015 @09:56AM
(#9524722)
OSM is full of local people mapping their area, and people care about the map (rather than helping out a big corporation).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google Map Maker will be temporarily unavailable for editing
by Fogest on Monday May 11, 2015 @10:08AM
(#9524819)
You can still care about mapping an area and use Google Maps though. And I don't see the issue with helping a big corporation. They provide a free mapping service with realtime traffic data, satellite views, and more. I don't see how contributing back is so wrong. Why does it matter who made the software and runs it?
Re:Google Map Maker will be temporarily unavailable for editing
by Piskvorrr on Monday May 11, 2015 @11:35AM
(#9525498)
Maybe it doesn't matter to you - which is perfectly fine by me, I respect your choice. As for me, I've had "my" data (edits which I have contributed) in too many projects, only to have the "oh, and we're shutting the service down/restricting access/whatever, and no, you can't have the data, all ours!" happen to me.
I'm certainly not expecting Google Maps to go under, but I don't like the idea "sure, we will gladly take your data, but you can only do X, Y, and Z with them, and only as long as we're not angry at you." In other words, I have hit the limits of GMaps usefulness for my uses; I understand this doesn't necessarily happen to everyone :)
(Also related: in my geographic locations of interest, OSM is now a workable alternative - compared to five years ago, when I was struggling to fit within Google's terms, because there was no usable alternative for me then)
Re:Google Map Maker will be temporarily unavailable for editing
by Fogest on Monday May 11, 2015 @12:01PM
(#9525678)
Don't get me wrong here, I do contribute to OSM, in fact I even contribute GPS traces. I do believe that OSM is great, I am just stating that there are some things that are holding me back from using it for navigation :(
Re:Google Map Maker will be temporarily unavailable for editing
by Piskvorrr on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @04:53AM
(#9530332)
It is indeed superior (due to the traffic data), and I also use it via Waze. It would be miraculous for OSM to be better than Google Maps in every aspect. I was referring to the "contributing to the map" aspect here.
Re:Google Map Maker will be temporarily unavailable for editing
by rmc on Monday May 11, 2015 @10:11AM
(#9524835)
Yes, people's opinions aren't all the same. But some people feel less motivated to give free labour for the benefit of another company, and would rather work on something communal which everyone benefits from