Re:Do you understand this first-grade child's homework?
by RiderOfGiraffes on Friday November 20, 2009 @06:00AM
(#952233)
> ... raw memorization daily. It's not pretty.
> I don't think it's highly underrated.
Raw memorization is dreadfully damaging. Equally, having to add 5 and 8 by counting up is a complete block to other tasks. What's needed is a range of techniques and skills, each assisting the others, and each helping students to get that insight that stops math being a collection of tricks and unmotivated rules, and starts it being a coherent set of principles, facts, tools and techniques.
Re:Do you understand this first-grade child's homework?
by rdtsc on Friday November 20, 2009 @08:50AM
(#952383)
I think they should start with memorization, and let each individual develop they own heuristics and shortcuts. When those abstract shortcuts are enforced and don't match with the ones a person is already using, it can get confusing.
I see 8+3 as a number in the lowish tens. If I want the exact result I quickly increment "9-10-11" in my head. Some special cases (0,1,9 and 5+5) are easier.
I guess ability in arithmetic isn't really correlated with ability in calculus, etc., since math has always been my forte.
I'm studying at a japanese university right now and I see the effect of raw memorization daily. It's not pretty. I don't think it's highly underrated.