Which studies show that? Most studies I'm aware of show that severity is a very weak deterrent and that certainty is much more effective [1].
> The Institute of Criminology at Cambridge University was commissioned by the British Home Office to conduct a review of research on major studies of deterrence. Their 1999 report concluded that “…the studies reviewed do not provide a basis for inferring that increasing the severity of sentences generally is capable of enhancing deterrent effects.”
> Daniel Nagin and Greg Pogarsky, leading scholars on deterrence, conclude that “punishment certainty is far more consistently found to deter crime than punishment severity, and the extra-legal consequences of crime seem at least as great a deterrent as the legal consequences.”
> researchers compared crime and punishment trends in the U.S., England, and Sweden, and failed to find an effect for severity. The statistical associations were weak and even when there was a negative relationship between severity of punishment and crime rates, the findings were not strong enough to achieve statistical significance.
http://www.sentencingproject.org/doc/Deterrence%20Briefing%2...
I contend that cattle theft is typically planned in advance and not a spur-of-the-moment offense.
It may be the case that this penalty is excessive and unjust, but that doesn't mean it is ineffective.