Re:Despite DNA, the Rapist Got Away
by allendoerfer on Sunday May 10, 2015 @01:21PM
(#9520577)
I wanted to find out what the statute of limitation for rape is in the USA, because under German law (20 years starting with the victims 18th birthday), the rapist could very well be punished. And found out, that each state has their own regulation. I am all for federalism, but 16/50 different rape laws?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Despite DNA, the Rapist Got Away
by koenigdavidmj on Sunday May 10, 2015 @01:38PM
(#9520639)
Federal law is allowed to exist for a fairly short list of things in the Constitution, with regulating interstate commerce being the justification for most federal laws. It's not just a place to put anything we deem really important.
Even murder is usually a state crime unless it happens in DC or somehow affects interstate commerce.
That's taking a pretty kind view of the Fed's adherence to the Constitutional limits on its power. If it were important enough to the Federal government, Congress could use the club of taxation and federal grants to force the states to toe the line. See for example the peculiar uniformity in laws related to the drinking age, drivers' licenses, etc.; see also the questionable legality of the Affordable Care Act.
Re:Despite DNA, the Rapist Got Away
by koenigdavidmj on Monday May 11, 2015 @02:41PM
(#9526905)
There is usually only a token nod to interstate commerce, but it still exists.
As one example, there was a federal law known as the Gun Free School Zones Act that banned possessing a firearm within 1500 feet of a school (unless it was on private property, encased and locked, the possessor had a concealed pistol license, or a couple of other exceptions). In the case US v. Lopez, it got shot down as unconstitutional. It immediately got re-passed with the caveat that it affected any firearm that "has moved in or that otherwise affects interstate or foreign commerce", which of course is almost all of them.
I don't think it's unfair to say that the farcical invocation of interstate commerce in the repassage of the GFSA bolsters my point rather than refutes it... and the courts seem largely willing to go along with even the thinnest of rationales for Congress to legislate on matters for which it really has no Constitutional authority.
It's not that different from all EU states each having their own criminal codes. Of course, there is no U.S. state as large as the UK, France or Germany, but you have multiple European states the size of some American states.
I assume you mean in population. Texas is almost as big as France, much bigger than Fermany, and Alaska is much bigger than any of them.
Old joke: if Alaskans get tired of hearing that Texas is the second largest state, they'll cut Alaska in half to make Texas third.
Re:Despite DNA, the Rapist Got Away
by allendoerfer on Sunday May 10, 2015 @04:55PM
(#9521277)
Population wise the big EU states are much bigger than the big US states. Aside from that: You are right and it makes total sense to unify criminal laws and prosecution in a borderless area.