What the jury thinks about possible rape cases is of course depended on societies overall attitude to the crime and the involved group of persons. To give an extreme example: I would say, that a few years ago, many would never think that a priest could also be a rapist. Without the possibility in mind it is hard to convict somebody of something.
So we have to be very careful. There are a few cases of people ruining other peoples lives by accusing them, but most of the time, when somebody claims to be a rape victim and you have found DNA samples, probably it was indeed rape.
If you elect them, they will invariably go tough on crime, and have a huge conflict of interest in finding people guilty.
If you don't elect them and they are appointed who appoints them and how can you prevent the ultimate check on the state's power from being corrupted?