News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent... by ZeroGravitas on Saturday May 09, 2015 @10:36AM (#9516475)
The ballot would have had yes and no on it, if 85% voted for a third option in between then it would take some serious political wizardry to parlay that into a an immediate follow-on yes-no referendum.
Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent... by notahacker on Saturday May 09, 2015 @11:29AM (#9516639)
It's straightforward enough: you point out that the Scots have "almost unanimously rejected the status quo" and announce that following such a "clear mandate for change", supporters of independence, whose loyalties may have been swayed by the need to ensure at least some more political representation, must now be given a simple yes-no question. That's a rather easier trick to pull off than turning a referendum defeat into an unprecedented boost in Westminster seats months later. Pulling off a Yes vote might still be tricky, but just imagine a campaign for a "Yes" vote if it were happening, off the back of a resounding Devo Max win rather than a "No" win, maybe against the backdrop of a Conservative Westminster government pushing through Trident renewal and threatening to drag Scotland out of the EU with English referendum votes...

The only real difference is that a Labour party which opted to weight behind the Devo Max campaign rather being backed into sharing a "No" platform with the "Westminster parties" might not have lost so many votes to the SNP. That might have entered Cameron's political calculus too.