Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent...
by vidarh on Saturday May 09, 2015 @10:24AM
(#9516448)
Consider that the "horse trading" involves actually ensuring that more opinions are represented. If you support one of the larger parties, that means more compromises, yes. But for all of the people who supports smaller parties, it means their vote actually matters a bit too, and that they're not consistently railroaded by supporters of the biggest parties.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent...
by danmaz74 on Saturday May 09, 2015 @12:56PM
(#9516907)
That's a fair argument, but it's a matter of trade-offs. All that bartering means that no-one's program will be actually enacted, and when things don't go well there is nobody to take the actual responsibility - including voters, because everybody can always say "well but this wasn't what the party I voted for was proposing" - even if that party got a relative majority.
Personally, I favor a system where there is a clear winner chosen by the majority of popular vote, but where minorities have a "right to representation" where they can make their voices heard in the political debate. Not easy, but possible.