News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent... by danieltillett on Saturday May 09, 2015 @08:57AM (#9516224)
I can't believe you poms voted this down. Why wasn't it called preferential voting (like here in Australia) on the referendum?

I love preferential voting. You get to vote for a minor party or candidate while also ensuring the candidate you hate most does not benefit from you doing this. There is basically no need to vote strategically and back candidates you don't like purely because you hate them less than someone else. You just list all the candidates in your personal preference from 1 to x.

Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent... by Brakenshire on Saturday May 09, 2015 @09:08AM (#9516252)
The Yes campaign was somewhat naive and the No campaign played dirty. The new system was apparently going to cost £50m more per election, so they put up loads of posters showing children in incubators and soldiers wearing body armour, saying effectively 'these people will die if AV is introduced':

http://nicktyrone.com/sick-baby-billboard/

Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent... by danieltillett on Saturday May 09, 2015 @09:17AM (#9516274)
I am surprised that the Yes campaign didn't suggest saving 10x as much by getting rid of all elections and asking the Queen to come back as an absolute monarch.

I guess we Australian can't be too smug as we voted no in a referendum in 1988 asking if we wanted freedom of religion. Apparently the FUD then was over funding for religious schools.

Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent... by crdoconnor on Saturday May 09, 2015 @09:05AM (#9516241)
There was a lot of FUD put out against it. Since most people don't really understand voting systems, nor their pros and cons, I guess they voted for the devil they knew.
Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent... by bshimmin on Saturday May 09, 2015 @09:26AM (#9516304)
I think this is the key point. Proportional representation is very simple to understand, and likewise first-past-the-post (in its essence, at least; the actual implementation we have in the UK perhaps less so). Alternative vote is plainly more complex - first something happens, then perhaps something else happens, then... etc; it's not complex for smart HN readers, but even trying to explain it in a few words shows it's more involved than the other two systems.

I am fundamentally uncertain that a majority of the electorate understood AV when they were voting - and this was certainly supported by my own conversations at the time with moderately intelligent people who plainly did not understand it. And, in fact, the majority of the electorate did not even vote at all on the issue.

Proportional representation is undeniably more democratic than either FPTP or AV, but it does mean you end up having to live with the fact that a rather alarmingly large proportion of people have views that the majority find unsavoury (eg. the BNP managed nearly 2% of the votes in the 2010 election).

Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent... by crdoconnor on Saturday May 09, 2015 @09:42AM (#9516347)
>it does mean you end up having to live with the fact that a rather alarmingly large proportion of people have views that the majority find unsavoury

That's democracy for you.

Besides, the BNP arose from a climate of austerity and declining real incomes. If you have a functioning political system that doesn't do that to the majority, you deprive the unsavory minority of political oxygen.

Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent... by madaxe_again on Saturday May 09, 2015 @10:14AM (#9516424)
They ran the message "it's too complicated for you to understand", and most accepted that at face and spent no more thought on the matter.

Same phenomenon as "math/computer is hard" being acceptable and an excuse not to try, or even listen. You can see the roller shutter come down in their eyes.

Re:UK Election: What difference would proportional represent... by IanCal on Saturday May 09, 2015 @09:54AM (#9516380)
There was a pretty poor campaign around it, and only 42% of people bothered to vote.

The other consideration was that many people wanted a different system to AV.