From where I'm standing, the neighborhood groups preventing any new housing from getting built are the ones destroying the city.
There was a neighborhood meeting this week about building over 1,000 units of affordable housing on what is now a parking lot, and the majority of current neighbors expressed a preference for the parking lot. Please, convince me that a massive slab of asphalt is better for San Francisco than making room for 1,000 new working class neighbors.
"The neighborhood is mostly single family homes, and the people there are very resistant to the idea of “renters” (the code word they use for poor people) living in the neighborhood."
http://sfbarf.tumblr.com/post/116593748570/balboa-reservoir-...
Would you be OK with this principle if a white neighborhood wanted to enforce a "no black or brown people" rule? How about a "straight people only" rule? How about "no poor people"? This isn't a purely abstract question, but an actual question that has arisen repeatedly in the history of the US. Sunset Towns have been real things.
There is a difference between a neighborhood having a say in its future and a neighborhood having a dictatorial stranglehold on all changes within its bounds. Does the rest of the city have no say? The county? The state? The country?
Do you think it's OK for a city to tell a neighborhood that they need to accept a certain set of non-discriminatory zoning rules based on land use, even if it's not what the people there want?
Residents answer to their neighborhood, neighborhoods answer to their district, districts answer to the city, state, and so on.
How to respect individuals, communities, and a plan for the future across all of those lines of responsibility isn't answerable with a simple "yes" or "no"; however, the onus should be on the individuals requesting the change to 1) justify its necessity and value, 2) quantify its cost to existing residents, and 3) recommend mechanisms for remediation or renumeration for externalities imposed upon the local residents by whatever project is imposed upon them to the benefit of the broader populace.
http://www.venere.com/blog/images/positano-streets-amalfi-co...
http://www.china-tour.cn/images/Lijiang/Lijiang-Nightlife.jp...
https://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5159/5889050432_4f8d86e07f_b.j...
My point is that some of the great and beautiful narrow cobble stone streets in, say, Boston or Philly, to use US examples, weren't built to handle heavy street traffic. Transforming high volume automobile streets to the walkable ideal is inevitably going to cause some headaches.
Out of all the places and times and people who've talked of building more housing as destroying the city, most of them were just rich, white landowners who didn't want immigrants, minorities, and jobseekers ruining their views.
I'm not saying you're any such person, but your position is objectively furthering the interests of rent-seeking landowners as the expense of the marginalized and the exploited. Real equality can proceed only when housing is available as close to construction cost as possible, or better yet, cheap as free.
I live somewhere that's 1) expensive, 2) low-density.
The expense is because the low density makes this a nice place to live; more people want to live here than can fit here.
If we simply allowed development to meet demand, then this place wouldn't be a nice place to live anymore.
The solution is to pay a living wage such that everyone that works here can afford to live here. The solution isn't to socialize housing.
Or do you expect people to just live somewhere else nearby?
Have you considered the possibility of region-wide consequences when supply and demand set in, companies pay better, people commute farther, and live in other cities too?
SF is maybe 35 square miles, once you take out the parks.
Why don't we build new housing in Palo Alto? Or better yet, rezone Stanford or Atherton?
I guess affluent monocultures must be protected.
Come on. Say what you mean. You don't want things to change, because then things would be different and you'd have to have Those People in your wonderful inclusive life.
And that would be bad. So down with inclusiveness!
But let's not get caught up in that yet. In what way would density "objectively and significantly decrease the quality of life of all existing residents"? From your phrasing, you clearly have solid evidence and objective metrics for your rather strong claim about both significance and universality.
Seriously, housing is one of the least elastic markets out there. Everyone needs exactly one home, everything else is secondary.
- Bust: Demand dries up from the beleaguered economic sector (e.g., tech in SF after .com crash, finance in NYC post-housing bubble crash). Prices drop. Demand rises, fast, with residents moving in from the boroughs/suburbs.
- Boom: Demand is extremely high from the booming economic sector. Prices increase to match, unmet demand drops as those outside the boom sector move out to the boroughs/suburbs.
You can never build enough housing in a high-demand city without destroying the city; the demand is too elastic, the incentives between neighborhoods/culture and developers too misaligned.
San Francisco's problem is in the externalities levied by the immature VC-valley monoculture; significant increases in market rate housing density bring corresponding increases in the societal/cultural problems underlying this issue.