News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by petercooper on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:13AM (#9511100)
The Liberal Democrats have always (well, till now) been at their strongest in progressive rural areas that have little to no urban blight (so, much of Scotland, much of the South West, parts of East Anglia, Northumberland, mid Wales).

Now for my personal opinion.. I would credit this to them being the most "centre" of the parties - they're progressive without being overtly socialist, and that appeals to the "hey, I'm still cool" element of the rural middle class that still likes their cars, village fetes, and horsey stuff, but is also pro gay marriage, pro equality and pro welfare.

Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by k-mcgrady on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:32AM (#9511196)
>> "I would credit this to them being the most "centre" of the parties"

I thought the liberal democrats (at least before the coalition) were the most left leaning of the major parties.

Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by buro9 on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:38AM (#9511230)
Labour are the most left leaning, but still kinda centrist. Liberal Democrats are relatively centrist for the major parties but still quite right:

This sums it up best... the UK is mostly a right leaning authoritarian country, we vote on the relative differences between parties rather than the overall thing.

http://www.politicalcompass.org/uk2015

Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by thomasfoster96 on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:04AM (#9511386)
Is it just me or does politicalcompass.org seem to skew everything towards right wing authoritarianism?
Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by masklinn on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:11AM (#9511443)
Seem about right to me. The NZ[0] or German[1] compasses cover much more of the spectrum, especially towards left-libertarianism. It's not politicalcompass's fault that US politics live entirely in the right-authoritarian corner and English politics have significantly shifted towards it with New Labour's realignment on US democrats.

[0] http://www.politicalcompass.org/nz2014

[1] http://www.politicalcompass.org/germany2013

Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by thomasfoster96 on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:17AM (#9511482)
Yes those NZ and German charts look a bit more balanced - but being from Australia, their 2013 Aussie election chart is just a bit silly to be honest - two of the parties listed had no chance of even getting any seats, and despite most parties being fairly centrist in their economic policy they all seem to be bunched up in the top right corner. My only guess is that the analysis was done using a small sample of international media.
Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by buro9 on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:07AM (#9511417)
I think it's just the world we live in. The left and more liberal options exist but none of them are mainstream and we mentally re-draw the extents of the political compass to cover the politics we experience (the major parties).
Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by petercooper on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:15AM (#9511469)
That should be how the political compass is drawn since it is based on human experience, no?

I think that chart is crazy though. The Conservatives are far from a far right party. Christ, if you dropped the Conservatives in America, they'd be considered a right bunch of commies - even the Democrats would be off the scale to the right by that chart.

Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by masklinn on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:19AM (#9511493)
> That should be how the political compass is drawn since it is based on human experience, no?

AFAIK, the political compass attempts to assess an absolute scale across world politics, not local choices.

Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by thomasfoster96 on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:23AM (#9511530)
Still a bit odd the concentration of western political parties in the right-wing authoritarian section of the graph - unless there's a whole lot of countries with extreme left-wing governments which are very pro-choice, which I highly doubt.
Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by masklinn on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:50AM (#9511692)
> Still a bit odd the concentration of western political parties in the right-wing authoritarian section of the graph

Dunno, if you consider that much of the anglosphere is patterning itself more and more after US politics which lives solely in the top-right corner of the top-right quadrant it makes sense that they would coalesce there. And "labour" parties have definitely been shifting their stances towards US dem inspiration.

Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by thomasfoster96 on Friday May 08, 2015 @10:37PM (#9515228)
I'd still say the UK and Australia are a fair way away from the American parties (particularly the republicans).
Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by thomasfoster96 on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:13AM (#9511455)
Having had a look through political compass's past predictions (primarily Australian, since I'm Australian) their analysis is very odd. I mean, there is no way that you can seriously put three quarters of the parties on the top right 16th of the chart.
Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by masklinn on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:42AM (#9511246)
They were the centrist party, labour was the binary left (centre-left). The Dem part of LibDems had split from labour in the 80s because labour was getting too left-wing. With New Labour moving to centre-right, LDs moved to right-right (explaining the coalition being "basically tory"). The left-leaning parties remaining are the SNP (center-left) and the Greens (left) (Sinn Féin can be ignored as they refuse to sit in Westminster)
Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by petercooper on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:36AM (#9511215)
Long-term, no, but due to New Labour (1997-2010) being slightly right of centre, the Lib Dems were "left" in relation to that, yes, but not in relation to Labour's traditional position.

I am not particularly savvy when it comes to Scottish politics, but I was under the impression that Scottish Labour was considered somewhat more left than Labour proper even during the New Labour years.

Re:Mapping Scotland's Dramatic Shift in Political Geography by collyw on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:51AM (#9511305)
http://politicalcompass.org/uk2015

They are all right wing.