News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Dawn of AI: How to ensure the promise outweighs the p... by coldtea on Thursday May 07, 2015 @11:14AM (#9505622)
>It's ignorant of the entire literature on superintelligence because it assumes that superintelligences will behave like cooperating humans.

That's at best a peripheral detail to the parallel the parent tries to draw.

Real AI might as well behave in any odd way -- the real point is that something like "more powerful than human intelligence" already exists, in the form of these aggregate entities.

Re:The Dawn of AI: How to ensure the promise outweighs the p... by SCHiM on Thursday May 07, 2015 @11:49AM (#9505904)
Except they're not really superhumanly intelligent in the sense that AGI is superhumanly intelligent.

Sure a lawyers office is probably able to to tackle more cases that a single lawyer. A big multinational with momentum probably a lot more power than a single human.

But say you put 5 Einsteins together, before he invented his theories. Do you think that his discovery process would go 5x faster? Does the team-einstein suddenly get 5x smarter?

I think not, the point here being that while corporations are super-human, they are not in the same league as true AGI. And that containment of corporations/governments is not a good place to learn about the containment of true AGI.

Re:The Dawn of AI: How to ensure the promise outweighs the p... by coldtea on Thursday May 07, 2015 @11:56AM (#9505972)
>But say you put 5 Einsteins together, before he invented his theories. Do you think that his discovery process would go 5x faster? Does the team-einstein suddenly get 5x smarter?

Maybe not, but it sure as hell be more than "1 Einstein unit" smarter. Whether that's 1.2 or 5 depends on various elements, but it surely would beat a single Einstein, if not by anything else, by mere ability to break down a problem to study in parts and assign it to each Einstein.

I mean, that's the reason we have research teams with multiple researchers on the same team.