Re:Weave is kinda slow
by juliangregorian on Thursday May 07, 2015 @02:17AM
(#9503549)
Weave had their reasons. I don't profess to understand the space well enough to chime in, but that much is clear from the twitter excerpt.
Re:Weave is kinda slow
by weavenetwork on Thursday May 07, 2015 @06:34AM
(#9504092)
We did not roll our own crypto. We used NaCl. The rationale is explained here - http://weaveworks.github.io/weave/how-it-works.html#crypto We agree that other approaches are possible, but this is the one we picked for our first version.
This isn't to say that there's never room for improvement in the crypto space - I personally disagree with the assertion that rolling one's own crypto is inherently bad in all cases, and instead believe that we need a maximum of innovation attempts now so that they can be evaluated and audited and identified as useful - but unless you're actually fixing a problem, Not-Invented-Here syndrome is dangerous and a waste of time better spent elsewhere.