1990 - reaching all-time highs, 'exceptional period'
1991 - reaching all-time highs, 'exceptional period'
1992 - reaching all-time highs, 'exceptional period'
1993 - reaching all-time highs, 'exceptional period'
1994 - reaching all-time highs, 'exceptional period'
1995 - reaching all-time highs, 'exceptional period'
>I think there's just too much money sloshing around right now.
Why? Are you the tastemaker in how much money supply there should be? We have inflation numbers to help dictate that. If inflation isn't above its target, then there isn't too much supply.
I was visiting a friend last night, who is looking to buy her first house.
She told me that she's been having trouble because people are showing up for $300k houses ($150-200k 5 years ago) and offering, same day, without an inspection, $600k cash offers.
That tastes funny.
I think what's most amazing to me is how much realtors are making right now. I'm not sure if it's still standard for the buyer's agent & seller's agent to each take a 3% cut like elsewhere in the country, but I've gotten multiple postcards where a realtor has moved $10MM-$15MM of inventory, in the last quarter, in my neighborhood alone. A 3% cut of that ain't a bad gig...
In an extreme seller's market, it's effectively equivalent to not providing even a listing price. They might as well say $0, because there will be plenty of buyers who show up to establish market price immediately (and then bid up from there).
Why the anxiety??
With the housing bubble, it was very clear that the traditionally correlated mortgage and rental prices had separated, signalling that mortgages were in a bubble.
Pointing a chart and saying it's high doesn't prove anything. You need to show signals other than the federal reserve moderating inflation (which is normal).
[1] http://www.fool.com/investing/general/2014/04/18/why-the-dow...
(1) Its correlation with the S&P 500 is insanely high. So, just using it as a proxy for the S&P is fine.
(2) We've tracked the DJIA going back over a hundred years, so that data is readily available.
Overall, the S&P 500 is a better index, but criticizing someone for using it in their analysis isn't worth the distraction from their actual thesis.
One, the real estate market is once again through the roof while homeownership is at the lowest it's been in decades. Seems to me that wealthy people, domestic and foreign, are parking their money in real estate assets, and banks refuse to go through with the foreclosures they've been holding onto since around '09
Next is oil. It's possible that the full brunt of the collapse in oil prices hasn't been felt, but most oil companies were profitable to the tunes of billions of dollars, again. Profit margins were only off about 30% from last quarter, and the predicted merger/acquisition apocalypse analysts were predicting hasn't materialized, while oil prices are on their way to recovery, even though the dollar is ridiculously strong against other currencies at the moment
Hiring has pulled back, wages are stagnated, consumer spending is down, but the stock market is at record highs. Honestly, for the most part I wish the government had let it crash
http://home.earthlink.net/~intelligentbear/dj-lt-infl.gif
When you take inflation into account, it doesn't look nearly so interesting.
Yes, if the market is overinflated, it's because growth itself has failed to happen.
In this case I'm not too worried about public equities, it seems to be everything else right now.
The basic problem is that every major economy is simultaneously trying to restart its growth through exports. We're in a currency war.
The currency war This may explain why inflation has not followed, but my current favorite explanation is that the middle class has not seen signifigant wage growth over the last 30 years. You only see monetary CPI if more money is chasing fewer goods, but that requires people to have more money to perform that chase. This (combined with the oil panic) was a big reason for the inflation that happened in the 70s: printed money largely went into giving workers a raise, instead of being put into financial investments. I'm not an expert on modern monetary inflation (is anybody at this point?), but when you drop the interest rates to the lowest point in 50 years and have near zero inflation, there's something weird going on.
Most of the wealth generated here is not going into the hands of the middle class. The wealthy invest their money into big (and/or risky) assets like what's being invested in right now. I'm not just talking about a cigar-chomping Daddy Warbucks character when I say "wealthy", I also mean entities like corporations that are able to take out money at very low cost. This isn't necessarily a bad thing, as corporations use this money to invest and strategize. But we're not seeing a lot of gains for the majority of Americans, and that's a problem, especially when things they need (like real estate) spike up a lot.
It's important to note that monetary inflation is not the same thing as the cost of a good going up. For example, if oil becomes more expensive, it makes goods increase in price due to the increased cost of producing and shipping those goods. That's not the same thing as prices going up because there's more money chasing the same amount of resources. Production cost inflation doesn't bother me as much as monetary inflation does (frankly, we need expensive oil to signal that it's time to look for alternatives), but we're not really seeing either right now.
The one positive metric I'm seeing for the markets, ironically, has been a reason for a lot of it's volatility lately. When oil goes down in price, it's good for the economy, and consumers have more money to purchase things. It's been estimated that 80% of the stock market benefits from lower energy costs, but of course, people still freaked out when oil tanked and sold a lot of stocks, especially in the oil sector.
Ultimately, actual inflation would be a good thing, by helping households deleverage. Instead, the asset bubbles are likely to cause more household debt, and around we will go until another crash.
I honestly think there will be open revolution in at least some countries (well, Greece is already in such a state!) due to the radical detachment of the capital markets, and the political class held captive to those capital markets, from the household sector.
P/E ratios are a bit high compared to average, but not crazily so.
Note that it's even higher now on the end of that chart, so push it to 18,000 and you've got the comparison.
That chart, at a bare minimum, whether you think we're dealing with "irrational exuberance" or not, should tell you that we're in an exceptional period in the stock market.
Chart two, federal funds rate, 1954 through 2009: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/31/Fed...
That funds rate is still that low. Whether you think it's too low or not, it's pretty obvious that this is an exceptional period for access to low-interest money.
I'm watching the real estate market spike up much faster than wages (again), and billions get poured into tech companies who's business model really just isn't there and/or heavily depends on advertising (advertising rates collapsed after 2000, by a lot). I was worried about the valuations a year ago, and now they're even higher. And of course, it's pushing a lot of private valuations up too. The more money publicly traded corporations have, the better your chances of selling a private company at a high value, or going public without good fundamentals.
I think there's just too much money sloshing around right now. Excess money doesn't go into CPI anymore, it more often creates valuation fevers. I don't think the overnight rates should have been this low for so long. And I'm pretty worried about what's going to happen when they finally start raising them, but not as worried as what happens if they continue to leave them as-is.