I'm genuinely curious why you hold that opinion, especially in context of a thread that discusses a service that's available through the standard hbase api
Without support for co-processors in BigTable I would hardly call it 'standard' API. Also the implementation of buffered mutation, a key attraction in HBase 1+ for fast non-blocking writes, is different enough in bigtable that you might have to change application code to work it consistently. It's nice though that bigtable API have references to HBase bugs :)
> HBase 1.0.0 has a bug in it. It returns maxSize instead of the buffer size for > getWriteBufferSize. https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HBASE-13113
Ever try porting a customer using cloudformation templates and autoscaling groups over to another cloud service? Or reimplementing s3 or EBS semantics? It can be done, but definitely non-trivial... lockin++
Re:Announcing Google Cloud Bigtable
by megaman821 on Wednesday May 06, 2015 @11:08AM
(#9499186)
I think of the three AWS services you named, only Dynamo can't easily be ported out.
Redshift use Postgres drivers. EMR uses the HBase API.
Redshift uses Postgres drivers, but does not use Postgres semantics. Important to consider if you're using any nontrivial amount of data, because porting it even to other cstore databases will require a lot of thinking and probably some munging-at-scale.
Google Cloud is a much bigger vendor lock-in, you could not setup the same environment outside of it.